Takeaways

#
  • Menaker classified trades by both adherence to the plan and financial result.
  • A profitable rule-breaking trade could conceal weak process; a planned stop-out could reflect sound execution.
  • Reviewing the order of trades could reveal whether impulsive decisions followed winning streaks or repeated stop-outs.
  • When a trader wanted to increase size, Menaker recommended asking how they expected to handle an adverse move in the larger position.

A profitable trade could conceal a process problem. In his October 4, 2024 Off the Charts interview with Steve Strazza and Sean McLaughlin, Andrew Menaker asked traders to examine how they made their money, including the wins that came from breaking their own rules.

The trading psychologist’s practical exercise was to classify trades at the end of each day or week. The record needed two pieces of information: whether the trader followed the plan and what happened to the money.

Give the process its own score

Menaker described four categories:

  • Type one: Followed the plan and made money.
  • Type two: Followed the plan and exited at the predefined stop.
  • Type three: Departed from the plan and lost money.
  • Type four: Departed from the plan and made money.

The fourth category deserved particular attention. A favorable result could make a weak process look successful. Menaker wanted traders to identify that distinction instead of treating every profitable outcome as evidence that they had acted well.

The second category made the opposite distinction possible. A stopped-out trade could still reflect faithful execution of the plan. His exercise gave the trader a way to assess that execution separately from the outcome they could not control.

Review the sequence, not just the entries

Strazza asked whether writing the trades down was enough. Menaker said the trader also needed to return to the record and look for patterns.

For some people, departures from the plan appeared after a string of profitable, well-executed trades, as confidence rose. For others, they followed a series of planned stop-outs. Reviewing the sequence could help the trader recognize the circumstances that preceded impulsive decisions.

Menaker had described impulsivity as a frequent reason clients sought his help: entering too soon, trading too often or taking too much size. The journal offered a concrete way to examine those behaviors in their own trading history.

Ask what a larger position would change

McLaughlin then described a person he mentored who wanted to move into larger futures contracts despite not yet showing consistent results with smaller ones. He was concerned that increasing size would come too soon.

Menaker suggested questions: Why did the trader want to get bigger? How did they expect that to help? What would happen when a trade moved against the larger position, and how would they react?

He preferred exploring those expectations to issuing a blunt instruction. In his experience, telling a resistant trader what to do could make them dig in. A well-chosen question could instead create a moment in which they considered the consequences for themselves.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-10-04 episode.

What was a type-four trade in Menaker’s framework?

A trade that made money despite a weak process or departure from the plan. He wanted traders to recognize that the profit did not validate how they had traded.

Link to this answer

Why review the journal after recording the trades?

Menaker said patterns could emerge in the sequence, including departures from the plan after a winning streak or a series of planned losses. Those circumstances could help a trader recognize a recurring problem earlier.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .