Takeaways

#
  • Gatlin interpreted gold's elevated monthly momentum as evidence of trend strength rather than an automatic reversal signal.
  • The hosts used miners' performance relative to gold to assess whether the advance was extending beyond the metal itself.
  • Their silver and GDX objectives remained historical forecasts, supported by their reading of charts and skeptical participation.
  • Energy was a developing case: bond weakness supported it, while a meaningful TLT recovery would challenge Perz's view.

Sam Gatlin and Jason Perz remained strongly bullish on precious metals in the September 25, 2025 Gold Rush episode. Their central argument was that the size of the advance did not, by itself, establish that the trend had ended. They looked instead at mining-stock leadership, relative performance and the degree to which investors appeared to have embraced the move.

They also began looking beyond precious metals. Energy was attracting their attention, but its case depended on additional evidence from energy stocks, bonds and yields.

Overbought readings reflected a strong trend

Gatlin opened with a long-term gold chart supplied by Larry Thompson. Its monthly momentum reading was unusually high. Where skeptics might read that as a reason the rally had to stop, Gatlin saw evidence of a powerful uptrend.

His argument concerned the interpretation of momentum. An overbought condition could accompany sustained strength rather than identify an immediate reversal. He remained bullish.

Perz then compared mining-related funds with broader market sectors. In his presentation, gold miners and metals-and-mining stocks had been among the year's strongest areas. He preferred to focus on that leadership rather than assume the best performers had automatically exhausted their opportunity.

Miners were strengthening relative to the metal

The hosts highlighted a ratio of the Gold Bugs mining index to gold futures. They interpreted its move out of a long consolidation as evidence that mining shares were beginning to outperform the underlying metal more decisively.

That relative comparison mattered because owning gold and owning a mining business were different expressions of the theme. Stronger mining shares suggested the advance was extending into a more aggressive part of the market in their framework.

Silver and silver miners added to that view. Perz continued to expect silver to reach $50 by year-end, while Gatlin emphasized that it had not yet cleared that major reference at the time of the recording.

They also discussed GDX approaching or moving through its old 2011 high area. Gatlin identified roughly $100 as a longer-term extension objective, and Perz agreed that the trend could continue.

Sentiment supported their case without replacing the charts

Gatlin and Perz believed participation still lagged the price advance. They pointed to central-bank buying, a fund-manager survey and limited interest from investors they had recently met.

They also discussed high short interest and a reduced number of shares outstanding in GDX as signs that the rally had not attracted universal enthusiasm. Those observations were part of their sentiment argument.

The hosts expected stronger interest eventually to extend toward smaller miners and exploration companies. They saw that as the next stage of the cycle. Their preference for moving down the size spectrum followed their confidence in the broader trend.

Energy still required a different set of signals

The discussion then shifted to rising yields and energy. Perz thought higher U.S. yields remained a possible surprise despite the Federal Reserve's recent rate cut. He distinguished the central bank's policy action from how longer-term bond yields might respond to inflation expectations.

Gatlin linked the energy case to a broader commodity chart and the yield curve. Perz focused on the relationship between energy stocks and long-duration bonds, represented by TLT. Continued bond weakness would support his energy outlook; a meaningful TLT recovery would make him reassess it.

He also wanted stronger confirmation from the energy-stock chart. The hosts were interested in a rotation developing alongside metals, rather than claiming that energy had already matched the miners' performance.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-09-25 episode.

Why did Gatlin remain bullish with gold overbought?

He interpreted the unusually strong monthly momentum as characteristic of a powerful uptrend. He did not treat an overbought reading alone as proof that the move had ended.

Link to this answer

What did miners' relative strength add to the discussion?

The hosts saw a mining-index-to-gold ratio leaving a long consolidation. They interpreted that as evidence that mining shares were beginning to lead the metal more decisively.

Link to this answer

What could challenge Perz's energy outlook?

A meaningful recovery in long-duration bonds, represented by TLT, would make him reconsider the energy case. He was watching that relationship alongside energy stocks and yields.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .