Takeaways
#- Gatlin and Perz remained bullish on the metals trends despite extreme momentum readings, while allowing for significant pullbacks.
- Perz let successful positions grow beyond their initial weights and used trailing exits rather than automatic rebalancing.
- They watched miners relative to gold and gold relative to stocks for evidence that the broader leadership could continue.
- Steel was a prospective breakout, while Perz wanted crude above $80 and XLE above $101 before pursuing the energy setup.
Gold had risen enough to make investors uncomfortable. For Sam Gatlin and Jason Perz, that discomfort was not yet a reason to sell.
In the October 16, 2025 Gold Rush, the pair focused on how to manage an unusually strong trend once it had already become a large winner. Both were heavily exposed to precious metals, but Perz's answer to growing concentration was to follow his exits rather than repeatedly cut the position back to its original size.
They also looked beyond gold. Silver, platinum and palladium were participating, copper miners had broken higher, and steel producers were approaching a decision point. Crude oil remained the conspicuous exception.
Overbought readings had not ended the trend
Gatlin acknowledged that momentum readings in gold were extreme across several time frames. His longer-term outlook remained bullish, including an $8,000 cycle target, but he explicitly allowed for substantial corrections along the way.
Perz wanted to keep following the existing uptrend. He would become more cautious if the trend bent, miners began weakening relative to gold or silver lost strength. He was not yet seeing those warnings.
His argument rested on the contribution of unusually large winners. A trend follower could suffer many ordinary trades and still depend heavily on the occasional position that continued much further than expected. Selling merely because a rally had become unusual could cut off the very trade the method was meant to capture.
Perz allowed the allocation to expand
A viewer asked how much of their portfolios they had allocated to precious metals. Gatlin said approximately 30%. Perz estimated that gold, silver, platinum, palladium and miners together accounted for roughly 40% of his long-term portfolio at that point.
Perz described that as large for him. Some of the weight had developed through appreciation: a position that began at 5% did not automatically get cut back to 5% after doubling.
He also said he did not tighten stops simply because a winner had grown. He accepted giving back part of an advance when the trend eventually reversed, with trailing exits governing the decision.
That approach meant tolerating both larger concentration and a retreat from peak gains. Gatlin's question about shorter stops made the trade-off explicit; Perz preferred to preserve the original trend-following method.
Relative strength broadened the argument
The discussion moved from gold's dollar price to gold relative to the S&P 500. Gatlin saw a large base that could support a longer period of outperformance.
He distinguished relative performance from an outright price forecast. The ratio could rise with gold advancing faster than stocks, or with stocks falling while gold held up better.
Perz also liked the reversal in miners relative to the metal. They saw GDX and the mining industry as a way the precious-metals trend could express itself beyond bullion alone.
Silver's move through its long-standing price ceiling was another reason for their optimism. Gatlin identified $73 as an initial extension target, with larger possibilities beyond it. Perz discussed the prospect of reaching $73 before year-end, while acknowledging that a pullback and consolidation could arrive first.
Their preference was to continue managing existing positions through the trend. Perz specifically separated that from telling someone to initiate a new position immediately after the advance.
Steel had a different starting point
The industrial-metals charts offered an earlier-stage setup. Gatlin pointed to large base breakouts in XME and COPX, while steel producers were still coiling beneath resistance.
He saw potential for steel to follow the groups that had already moved. Perz agreed, but wanted to take opportunities as the individual breakouts appeared rather than buy every commodity on a single broad narrative.
Artificial-intelligence demand could help explain interest in some materials. For Perz, the more useful trading question remained which charts were actually resolving higher.
Oil still needed confirmation
The pair's commodity optimism did not extend to buying crude oil immediately. Perz wanted crude above $80 and XLE above $101 before becoming interested in that setup.
Until then, he saw a market still chopping around. Gold, silver and mining stocks were supplying the trends he wanted; oil had yet to earn the same treatment.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-10-16 episode.
How did Perz manage a winner that became a larger portfolio weight?
He allowed it to grow and did not automatically trim it to the original allocation. He also kept his trailing-stop approach rather than tightening solely because the position had appreciated.
What would have weakened their precious-metals view?
Perz wanted to watch for the trend bending, miners slowing relative to gold or silver losing strength. He said he was not seeing those signals at the time.
Why were they waiting on oil despite liking other commodities?
Oil had not produced the price confirmation they wanted. Perz identified crude above $80 and XLE above $101 as conditions that would make the setup more interesting.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .