Takeaways
#- Zabelin separated oil's immediate response to supply fears from the economic demand needed to sustain higher prices.
- Perz had taken a failed-breakdown signal but wanted a new 52-week high to strengthen his bullish assessment.
- Zabelin identified European defense spending as a specific driver, while limiting his claims about broader international leadership.
- The discussion treated a supply-driven oil shock as a possible inflation and growth problem that could support interest in gold.
Oil's sharp advance had brought a trading signal and a geopolitical question together on the June 19, 2025 Gold Rush Live. Jason Perz said he had become long after a failed breakdown. Geopolitical strategist Dimitri Zabelin wanted to distinguish the immediate fear of disrupted supply from the demand that could sustain higher prices.
They were discussing the Israel-Iran conflict as it stood that Thursday. Zabelin thought further escalation could produce another violent move in oil. He was less convinced that a price increase driven by supply fears would last if the outlook for economic growth remained weak.
A supply scare could move prices before barrels were lost
Zabelin's earlier oil outlook had emphasized the potential drag from tariffs and weaker growth. In his analysis, those forces could restrain demand even as military developments added a risk premium.
He distinguished an actual interruption to supply from investors anticipating one. Markets could react to the possibility of disruption before it occurred. That helped explain why a sudden rally did not, by itself, overturn his longer-term demand assessment.
The Strait of Hormuz was central to that distinction. Zabelin considered the probability of closure relatively small, but meaningful enough to watch. He believed the geopolitical circumstances had raised the risk compared with previous threats, and that prices would be substantially higher if markets expected a closure.
His oil thesis therefore had two time frames: a potentially abrupt response to escalating threats, followed by the question of whether economic activity could support the higher price.
Perz wanted more evidence from the chart
Perz had taken the failed-breakdown signal, but the amount of news driving the rally made him uncomfortable. He preferred advances that developed before a widely discussed catalyst.
He agreed that oil demand ultimately mattered. Less transportation and economic activity would work against a durable rise. At the same time, he was watching international growth and considered a stagflationary outcome possible, with higher costs and weaker activity occurring together.
A new 52-week high would have made him more bullish. Until then, he was following the position while questioning whether the rally had enough strength to continue. His entry and his request for further confirmation were separate decisions.
European defense supplied a more specific explanation
When the conversation turned to international stocks, Perz described broad strength across his overseas holdings. He was using relative performance to identify where money appeared to be moving.
Zabelin offered a narrower explanation for part of Europe's advance: the prospect of greater defense spending. He pointed to Germany's change in approach to budget constraints and the implications for military expenditure, along with strength in British, German and French defense contractors.
He did not extend that explanation to every international market. His own portfolio was concentrated in US technology, and he said he followed overseas stocks less closely. Perz, by contrast, was seeing trading signals across Europe, Asia and Latin America.
Gold depended on the kind of inflation shock
Zabelin saw central-bank reserve diversification as one source of demand for gold. He also distinguished an oil rally driven by a healthy economy from one caused by restricted supply.
In the first case, higher energy use accompanied stronger activity. In the second, an oil shock could raise costs and weaken growth. He thought gold could become more attractive under that stagflationary scenario. He also considered concerns about US debt a possible additional influence, while stopping short of calling them the dominant force behind gold.
Perz returned to relative strength. International leadership did not require US stocks to fall; other markets could simply rise faster. He did not know whether that leadership would last through the year or develop into a much longer cycle. His approach was to take the signals one at a time and keep checking where the strength remained.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2025-06-19 episode.
Why could oil rally while Zabelin remained concerned about demand?
He thought military escalation could raise fears of a supply interruption before one occurred. That immediate risk premium was different from the longer-term demand outlook, which he believed could be weakened by tariffs and slower growth.
What confirmation was Perz seeking after the oil entry?
He said he had become long following a failed breakdown. A new 52-week high would have made him more bullish, while the news-driven character of the advance left him questioning its durability.
How did Zabelin connect an oil shock with gold?
He distinguished rising oil demand in a healthy economy from restricted supply that raises costs and weakens growth. Under the latter, stagflationary scenario, he thought gold could become more attractive alongside demand from central-bank reserve diversification.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .