Takeaways
#- Perz distinguished March oil futures from the expiring front contract and waited for closing-price signals.
- Gatlin's equal-weight energy baskets revealed improvement that was less visible in crude or a concentrated services fund.
- Oil could outperform silver through a faster advance without requiring silver itself to fall.
- Their metals positions remained governed by trend and exit rules while they watched for separate energy buy signals.
Crude oil was weak, precious metals were strong and energy-service stocks were telling a more constructive story than the commodity itself. On the December 18, 2025 Gold Rush, Sam Gatlin and Jason Perz examined those differences without trying to make every chart support the same immediate trade.
They thought energy could improve. They also remained long precious metals and wanted price conditions to govern any change. The possibility that oil might eventually outperform silver was different from an instruction to sell silver or buy a falling oil contract.
The oil contract changed the apparent breakdown
Gatlin was reluctant to short crude oil at its new lows. He saw limited downside momentum and a divergence between oil and rising long-term bond yields.
Perz added a distinction about the contract being examined. He was looking beyond the expiring front month to March futures, where he said the same new low had not occurred. He also waited for closing prices, rather than treating every intraday move through support as a completed signal.
His bullish expectations did not remove the short-side rule from his system. He said a sufficiently weak close could still cause his fund to go short. The broader thesis and the actual trade therefore remained separate.
They also compared oil with copper, which was advancing alongside the rise in long-term yields. Perz thought oil could eventually catch up, but acknowledged that these markets could diverge for a time. He wanted to see oil establish an uptrend before treating the recovery as confirmed.
Equal weighting revealed a different energy picture
Gatlin showed an equal-weight basket of energy futures that included crude oil, heating oil, gasoline and natural gas. He considered the combined chart more consistent with a broad range or accumulation process than the persistent decline suggested by looking only at crude.
He then applied the same question to energy-equipment and services stocks. His equal-weight basket looked stronger than OIH, whose larger holdings exerted more influence on the fund. He described the broader group as building one base above another.
That mattered because weakness in a few heavily weighted stocks could obscure improvement elsewhere. Gatlin wanted to inspect the group underneath the headline fund, while Perz focused on the divergence between strengthening shares and weaker oil.
Neither treated the equity chart as proof that crude had already turned. Perz wanted the commodity's price to confirm the setup as well. Until then, the stronger stocks and the oil contract offered different levels of evidence.
Silver's strength did not have to end for oil to improve
Their discussion of oil relative to silver produced a useful disagreement. Gatlin questioned whether the ratio said much about oil at all, since silver's rapid advance could be driving most of the move.
Perz agreed that a change in relative performance need not mean silver fell. Silver could continue rising while oil began gaining faster. He did not know the timing and was not selling his silver positions on that possibility.
He wanted to remain open to buy signals in energy as they developed. That was consistent with his existing metals strategy: hold the established trend, use a trailing exit and avoid anticipating the end simply because the move had become large.
Metals leadership still had its own evidence
Gatlin compared gold and silver with platinum and palladium and preferred the relative leaders. He also examined junior gold miners against larger miners through the GDXJ-to-GDX ratio.
The junior-miner ratio had attempted and failed to break out before. It was approaching another test, which he regarded as a potential sign of increasing risk appetite within the metals market. He distinguished that developing signal from an already completed breakout.
Perz's exit process remained tied to price. He described using a trailing stop or a signal such as a 60-day low, rather than trying to guess the precise end of the metals advance. New energy opportunities could be added when their conditions appeared; they did not require abandoning the positions already working.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-12-18 episode.
Why did the oil futures contract matter to Perz?
He said the March contract had not made the same new low as the expiring front month. He also waited for closes, so an intraday move or a different contract could create a different apparent signal.
What did equal-weight energy charts add?
Gatlin saw a more constructive range in a basket of four energy futures and stronger structure in an equal-weight services group. Those views reduced the influence of any single commodity or heavily weighted stock.
How could oil improve relative to silver without a silver bear market?
Perz thought oil could eventually rise faster while silver remained in an uptrend. He kept his silver exposure and waited for energy buy signals rather than treating that possible rotation as an immediate switch.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .