Takeaways

#
  • Bartelloni used XLP relative to the NYSE Composite to monitor defensive leadership versus broader market strength.
  • He wanted a convincing daily or weekly ratio break below support before increasing stock exposure, with another lower support area as a later reassessment point.
  • IBM's limited follow-through and Netflix's missing reversal signal kept projected levels separate from confirmed changes in direction.
  • He saw a possible silver advance toward $60–$65 after resistance around $41–$42, but said he was not yet long.

James Bartelloni could see stock indexes moving beyond some of his resistance projections. He was still waiting for a different chart to confirm the advance: consumer staples measured against the broader New York Stock Exchange index.

Recording this Bart's Charts episode on July 11, 2025, before leaving for his birthday weekend, he described a market that remained difficult for him to read. Some bearish patterns had appeared, while others were close to failing. He was prepared to change his interpretation if price defeated the levels he was watching.

Why he compared staples with the broader market

Bartelloni divided XLP, the consumer staples ETF, by the NYSE Composite index, or NYA. When staples outperformed the index, that ratio rose. When the broader index did better, it fell.

He used that relationship to examine defensive behavior. Investors continuing to favor everyday necessities could produce a different signal from a broad advance in less defensive stocks.

On the historical chart he presented, important lows in the ratio had often accompanied stock-market peaks. That made the ratio's current support zone significant to him. He was interested in whether staples would begin outperforming again or whether the broader market could push decisively through the relative support.

His analysis combined measured moves, projections, retracements and earlier price structure. The support area reached back roughly 15 years on the chart, giving it more weight in his assessment than a short-term fluctuation.

The plan had two distinct stages

Bartelloni wanted a convincing daily or weekly close below the ratio's support before increasing his own long exposure to stocks. A break lower in that particular ratio would mean the broader market was strengthening relative to staples.

Below it, he identified another cluster of potential support near a 78.6% retracement. If the ratio traveled down to that area, he would reassess the stock-market advance, potentially take profits and consider a bearish position.

His timing work complicated the bullish opportunity. He believed the ratio was approaching a period, extending into August, when it could form another low. He described the cycle tool as approximate, and the price break he wanted had not occurred.

For him, the possible trade was a defined stretch between two areas on the ratio chart. It was not a reason to abandon the second area once the first gave way.

IBM and Netflix still needed follow-through

IBM illustrated why a close through resistance did not settle every question. Bartelloni had wanted a strong daily or weekly close above a major projection area. The stock had supplied a large candle, but he was disappointed by the subsequent follow-through and was watching weakness around $284.

Netflix presented a different problem. It had reached the projection near $1,298 that he had previously discussed as a profit-taking area. He was now watching for a reversal signal before treating the resistance test as a short setup.

He considered the chart vulnerable, but said the signal reversal had not yet appeared. Reaching the projected area and confirming a change in direction were separate observations.

Silver's upside case also included a waiting point

Bartelloni was more constructive on silver, although he said he was not yet long. His monthly analysis placed a substantial resistance area around $41–$42, including a projection near $41.70.

A decisive move through that zone could support an advance into roughly $60–$65 in his assessment. He expected resistance on the way and was still watching how the current pattern developed.

That distinction between an attractive projection and an actual position appeared repeatedly in the episode. At the close, he returned to the staples ratio: the break below support had not happened, so the first step of his stock-market plan was still to wait.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the episode recorded July 11, 2025.

Why would a falling XLP-to-NYSE ratio be constructive for stocks?

The ratio falls when the broader NYSE Composite outperforms consumer staples. Bartelloni wanted a decisive break of relative support as confirmation before increasing his own stock exposure.

Link to this answer

What was his plan if the ratio reached the next lower support area?

He would reassess near the cluster around the 78.6% retracement, potentially take profits in stocks and consider a bearish position. The first support break had not yet occurred in the recording.

Link to this answer

What did he want silver to do before the larger upside projection became relevant?

He identified resistance around $41–$42. A decisive move through it could support a projection around $60–$65, while he was still waiting rather than holding a long position at the time.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .