Takeaways

#
  • Imperial Oil’s long breakout attracted the hosts, but its persistent rally made a fresh tactical entry difficult.
  • Dunuwila discussed a pullback toward $60 or a tighter-risk entry, while Strazza wanted a new short-term consolidation.
  • Franco-Nevada’s recovery above broken support gave them a closer reference for a potential trade.
  • Carrier’s proposed setup required a move above $59–$60, with $57 as the downside reference and roughly $75 as an objective.

The requests arriving during the April 4, 2024 Chart Request Live were dominated by energy and materials stocks. Steve Strazza and Patrick Dunuwila understood the appeal: long consolidations were giving way to strong advances. Finding a new entry after those advances was proving harder.

Imperial Oil illustrated the problem. The chart was breaking out from a base stretching back to 2008, but the stock was approaching a ninth consecutive rising week. A compelling long-term structure had become an awkward place to begin a short-term trade.

Imperial Oil had already moved

Dunuwila liked Imperial Oil’s breakout and identified the $90s as a possible target area. He compared Fibonacci extensions drawn with closing prices and with absolute highs and lows, which pointed him toward that broad region.

The viewer’s question, however, was about getting in. Dunuwila preferred looking for a pullback toward $60. Entering immediately was another possibility, but he described pairing it with a tight stop around a recent intraday low. Neither approach eliminated the difficulty of buying after such a persistent advance.

Strazza wanted to see a short-term continuation pattern develop. If the stock paused for a few weeks and formed a small consolidation, that could provide a more useful structure for an entry. Dunuwila suggested that, within such a flag, an anchored volume-weighted average price from the top could help identify a subsequent turn upward.

They were willing to keep following a strong chart while waiting for it to offer a manageable trade. The lack of an easy entry was itself evidence of how persistent the buying had been.

Franco-Nevada was closer to a reference level

Franco-Nevada presented a different setup. Its chart had appeared to be forming a top, broken support around $106–$107 and then reclaimed that area. Dunuwila regarded the recovery as a failed topping pattern.

Because the price was closer to the reclaimed level, he found this trade easier to define than Imperial Oil’s extended advance. He discussed $107 as one possible risk reference and approximately $114, around a later low, as a tighter alternative.

He identified the former-high area around $160 as an initial objective and considered roughly $190 as a possible extension beyond it. The premise was that reclaiming broken support could lead to a substantial recovery; those higher levels depended on that recovery developing.

Strazza also liked the setup. Their enthusiasm came from the failed breakdown and the surrounding strength in metals, rather than from assuming that a familiar company name would necessarily lead the group.

Carrier still had a breakout to confirm

Carrier offered another comparison. The hosts saw a large advance followed by a consolidation with a cup-and-handle appearance. An earlier breakout attempt had failed, leaving time for a more developed handle.

Dunuwila thought the levels were particularly clear. He described a move above $59 as an entry condition, or $60 for someone who wanted more confirmation, with a possible objective around $75. A drop below $57 would undermine that proposed trade.

The failed first attempt did not automatically disqualify the chart. He compared it with other markets that had returned to old highs, struggled with supply and then consolidated before moving higher. Carrier’s pause was what made the next decision easier to define.

Near the end of the program, Strazza returned to the concentration of commodity requests. Many viewers traded on short time frames, while the charts looked most persuasive when zoomed out. After several months of momentum, he cautioned that a strong long-term base could coexist with a poor place to initiate a fresh tactical position.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-04-04 episode.

Why was Imperial Oil difficult to enter?

Its breakout had already produced a long run of rising weeks. The hosts liked the larger structure but wanted a pullback or a short consolidation that could make a new position easier to manage.

Link to this answer

What was the failed-top setup in Franco-Nevada?

The stock had broken support around $106–$107 and then reclaimed it. Dunuwila saw that recovery as a reason to examine a bullish trade, using nearby chart levels to define risk.

Link to this answer

What levels did they discuss for Carrier?

Dunuwila described a move above $59, or $60 for additional confirmation, with an objective near $75. He would not want the proposed trade to fall below $57.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .