Takeaways

#
  • Uber’s rebound weakened the bearish case, but Gatlin wanted a further move above $82 before considering a new trade toward $99.
  • The short-term e.l.f. bounce discussed in the chat did not repair the larger head-and-shoulders breakdown.
  • Gatlin used a $110–$120 area for Elastic’s developing base, with $130 as an initial objective.
  • Manhattan Associates needed to stabilize near its old highs before the panel would consider its decline resolved.

Uber had looked vulnerable to Sam Gatlin. By the February 10, 2025 edition of Chart Request Live, its rebound had forced him to reconsider. The stock had recovered from a position where he thought sellers could take control, and the failed bearish setup was now a reason to look more closely.

Gatlin and Patrick Dunuwila used the audience’s chart requests to distinguish several situations that could all look like a stock moving higher: a recovery that invalidated a bearish case, a short-term bounce within a decline and a developing base. Each required a different decision.

Uber had moved before a new entry became obvious

Gatlin explained why he had been cautious. Uber had failed to retain important lows, and its reaction to earnings had left the chart in a precarious position. Dunuwila had reached a similar conclusion when examining it the previous week.

The subsequent advance changed what the chart was saying. Gatlin described the inability of sellers to complete an apparent distribution pattern as a sign of underlying strength. He also examined Uber relative to the S&P 500, where he saw a possible inverse head-and-shoulders formation developing.

That did not mean he wanted to chase the immediate move. For someone who had missed the initial breakout, he saw little to do at that moment. The next important area was around $82, a shelf of previous highs where he expected sellers might appear.

A move above $82 would create a new trade to assess. Gatlin placed a possible objective near $99, with the round $100 level another potential obstacle. His revised view was constructive, but the proposed entry still depended on the stock clearing resistance.

e.l.f. could bounce without repairing its larger decline

The e.l.f. Beauty discussion began with a much weaker longer-term chart. Gatlin saw a completed head-and-shoulders top and a recent gap below its neckline. He regarded the breakdown as further evidence of damage after the stock’s earlier leadership.

A question from Kenny Glick in the chat introduced a shorter time horizon. Glick was considering holding shares above $72.50 following the reversal from the earnings gap down. Dunuwila noted that buyers had stepped in and the stock was following through higher.

Gatlin would not have chosen that trade for his own longer-term approach, but he understood the shorter-term case. The stock had recovered an anchored VWAP associated with the earnings gap, and a move toward filling the gap could offer a trade.

Even that recovery would leave the price below the neckline he had identified near $99. A trader looking for a brief rebound and an analyst concerned about the larger downtrend could therefore reach different decisions without disagreeing about the chart.

Elastic was building a base

Elastic presented another structure. Gatlin saw a broad recovery formation, with buyers preventing the stock from returning to its earlier lows. Whether the pattern was called a cup and handle or described more generally as a base mattered less to the discussion than its improving shape.

He treated roughly $110–$120 as the relevant area for a long position, explicitly describing a range rather than one exact price. An initial objective around $130 came before the much more distant former high near $190.

Elastic’s relative chart also interested him. Against the S&P 500, he saw a possible reversal that could begin a period of outperformance. Both the price chart and the comparison were developing setups, rather than completed future gains.

Manhattan Associates needed to stop falling first

Manhattan Associates supplied the cautionary example. Its sharp decline and deterioration relative to the S&P 500 gave Gatlin little reason to become interested in buying it.

He identified approximately $180–$190, the area of the prior cycle’s high, as a place where buyers needed to respond. Dunuwila stressed that anyone considering the stock should first allow it to stabilize. The existence of an old support area did not establish that the current decline had ended.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-02-10 episode.

Why did Gatlin change his view of Uber?

The stock recovered from a vulnerable position instead of completing the bearish pattern he had identified. He regarded that failure to break down as evidence of strength, while still waiting for a new entry condition.

Link to this answer

How could e.l.f. offer a bounce trade while its larger chart remained weak?

The discussion concerned different time horizons. A recovery from the earnings gap could produce a short-term move, but Gatlin’s longer-term chart still showed a breakdown below a neckline near $99.

Link to this answer

Did Gatlin give one exact entry level for Elastic?

No. He described roughly $110–$120 as the relevant range, with an initial objective around $130 and the former high near $190 farther away.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .