Takeaways

#
  • Gatlin liked Sibanye Stillwater’s larger trend but preferred renewed strength above roughly $8.50 to buying the pullback automatically.
  • He wanted a decisive Newmont close above about $82 before treating its long base as resolved.
  • The presenters used smaller position size and clearer risk references to distinguish speculative Hycroft exposure from a larger mining holding.
  • PBF and Eos had their own confirmation levels and potential resistance, despite fitting the broader interest in commodity and energy stocks.

Sam Gatlin liked the precious-metals trend, but his September 2, 2025 Chart Request Live review did not treat every attractive mining chart as an immediate purchase.

Sibanye Stillwater needed to regain strength after a pullback. Newmont was approaching a long-standing resistance level. Hycroft had already surged and required a different approach to position size.

Riley Rosebee, making his first appearance on the show, joined Gatlin in separating the broad theme from the decision in each stock. Their discussion moved from gold's renewed advance into the specific prices and risks that could make a trade manageable.

Sibanye Stillwater needed buyers to regain control

A viewer asked whether Gatlin remained constructive on Sibanye Stillwater after its recent pullback. He did.

He saw the stock moving from a long decline into a base and then a new advancing phase. The correction after that advance looked like a continuation pattern to him, with a longer-term objective back toward $20.

His preferred entry was more immediate and conditional. He wanted strength above roughly $8.50 before getting involved, rather than buying simply because the stock had fallen from its recent high.

Rosebee asked about a VWAP anchored to the 2021 peak. Gatlin acknowledged that the buyers' response near it could support a different, dip-buying approach. His own preference remained to wait for renewed strength.

The pair could therefore like the same larger chart while recognizing that the entry depended on the trader's method.

Newmont's large base had not yet resolved

Newmont's multidecade structure drew both presenters' attention. Gatlin identified about $82 as the level above which he wanted a decisive close.

He thought a breakout could eventually carry the stock through $100 and toward a higher extension. But the first condition was still unmet: a sustained move beyond resistance.

He was explicit that he did not want to buy just below that level. The length of the base made the possibility interesting; it did not remove the need for confirmation.

Asked whether investors from the 1980s were still waiting to sell near their old entry prices, Gatlin declined to make that the explanation. He cared more about the market repeatedly responding to the area than about guessing who might be trading there.

Relative strength supported the theme

Gatlin used miners' performance against the metals themselves to assess risk appetite.

Gold miners in GDX were strengthening relative to GLD. Silver miners in SIL showed a similar improvement against SLV. He considered those relationships more useful to his process than finding one news story to explain the whole move.

Junior gold miners had not yet produced the same decisive relative breakout. He acknowledged an earlier false start, even while remaining optimistic about another attempt.

That left room for the theme to broaden, but it also showed that confirmation varied within the group.

Hycroft called for a smaller commitment

Hycroft had risen sharply that day. Gatlin made an exception to the show's usual preference for larger companies, while emphasizing how speculative this particular miner was.

The pair discussed former price highs as possible risk references. Rosebee was uncomfortable with the distance to a stop for an immediate full position and suggested starting more gradually while waiting for a clearer structure.

Gatlin connected that to portfolio construction. A larger, established miner and a much smaller speculative company did not need equal position sizes merely because both belonged to the same bullish theme.

He also warned that a stock up roughly 18% could suffer a comparably sharp decline. The strong day did not make it a low-risk holding.

Refiners and energy storage offered different tests

PBF Energy led the conversation into refining. Gatlin liked the industry's relative strength and wanted PBF to show strength above roughly $28.50. He identified about $44 as a possible intermediate profit-taking area and the old highs near $60 to $62 as a larger objective.

Rosebee then brought Eos Energy. They saw price coiling beneath a descending trend line while dollar trading volume increased. Gatlin thought an upside resolution could be forceful, but also highlighted roughly $10.50 as an area where sellers might appear.

Gatlin wanted to see whether Eos could actually clear the trend line before treating the anticipated move as underway.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-09-02 episode.

Why did Gatlin wait for strength in Sibanye Stillwater?

He wanted evidence that buyers had regained control after the pullback. He identified roughly $8.50 as his immediate reference while retaining a longer-term bullish view.

Link to this answer

What had to happen before he would buy Newmont?

He wanted a decisive close above approximately $82. The large base was attractive, but he did not want to enter just below a level that had repeatedly acted as resistance.

Link to this answer

How did Rosebee approach Hycroft’s sharp advance?

He favored entering gradually rather than immediately building a full position after a large up day. The distance to a clear risk level mattered, particularly in such a speculative stock.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .