Takeaways

#
  • The speakers were bullish on precious metals while distinguishing the readiness of individual mining stocks.
  • Gatlin used Sibanye Stillwater's anchored average to frame risk; DePablos wanted Rio Tinto to reclaim its own reference first.
  • Trilogy Metals had potential within its range, but Gatlin preferred to wait for a breakout above the old highs.
  • Pagaya's recovery structure and Hippo's fresh breakout became the speakers' competing selections late in the show.

A strong commodity market did not make every mining stock equally ready to buy. Sam Gatlin and Alfonso DePablos spent the September 8, 2025 edition of Chart Request Live sorting through that difference, using viewer requests to compare established strength, unfinished bases and fresh breakouts.

Their enthusiasm for precious metals was clear. The gold-miner ETF GDX had returned to its 2011 peak, and Gatlin liked its improving performance relative to the S&P 500. He thought the longer-term reversal could matter more than the argument that the recent advance had become too hot.

But a promising industry backdrop still left a separate decision in each stock: where would buyers need to prove themselves, and what price behavior would undermine the setup?

A reclaimed level was different from a level still overhead

Sibanye Stillwater illustrated the first situation. Gatlin was constructive on SBSW while it remained above the volume-weighted average price anchored to the April 2021 high. That calculation followed the average price, weighted by trading volume, from a specific turning point. He treated it as a reference for whether buyers were maintaining control.

He did not want to own the stock below that line. For an additional purchase on strength, he watched roughly $9.75 to $10, with $14 as his next upside reference. DePablos agreed that holding above the anchored average made the bullish case easier to define.

Rio Tinto was not in the same position. DePablos wanted it to reclaim an anchored average near $66 before becoming more interested. Below it, he preferred to leave the stock alone. Gatlin also thought the chart needed more work.

Southern Copper offered another incomplete setup. The speakers liked the larger base and its position above an important anchored average, but DePablos still wanted a decisive move through roughly $104 to $105. Constructive structure did not eliminate the resistance directly ahead.

Potential inside a range was not the entry Gatlin wanted

Trilogy Metals made that preference particularly explicit. Gatlin saw room for the stock to rise toward its previous highs around $3, yet he did not want to buy simply because there was space inside the existing range. He preferred a breakout above those highs.

The speakers acknowledged that a move from $2 to $3 could itself be substantial. Gatlin still wanted more evidence before participating. The available upside and his preferred entry were separate considerations.

McEwen supplied a different kind of opportunity: a longtime underperformer catching up during a strong market for miners. Gatlin disliked its relative record against GDX but saw a developing base. DePablos identified approximately $12.50 as a useful risk reference, while both watched the anchored average from the 2016 high for further confirmation.

They were not claiming that the weaker stock had become the industry's leader. They were considering whether improving price action could support a catch-up trade despite its poor history.

Two fresh reversals competed for the best chart

Outside commodities, Pagaya and Hippo changed the discussion from waiting for a base to break to assessing an emerging breakout.

In Pagaya, Gatlin highlighted the large area of limited trading left by an earlier collapse. He thought a recovery through that area could travel quickly, while the short interest added another possible source of buying. DePablos used the low-$30s breakout area to frame the trade and discussed the old gap near $83 as an upside target. Those were expectations built around the chart's structure.

Hippo was breaking higher during the broadcast. Gatlin liked the force of the move but specifically wanted it to hold near those levels into the close. DePablos pointed to roughly $36 as a risk reference and also liked its relationship to the average price anchored from the IPO.

By the end, DePablos favored Pagaya for its combination of the base, gap and short interest. Gatlin chose Hippo's fresh reversal. Their selections differed, but both rested on identifiable price behavior that could be monitored after the show.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-09-08 episode.

Why did the speakers treat Sibanye Stillwater and Rio Tinto differently?

On September 8, 2025, they saw SBSW holding above the average price anchored to its 2021 high. Rio Tinto was still below the comparable reference DePablos wanted it to reclaim near $66.

Link to this answer

Why did Gatlin wait on Trilogy Metals despite seeing room for a rally?

He preferred a decisive break above the old highs around $3 rather than buying inside the existing range. Potential upside to resistance did not match his preferred entry.

Link to this answer

What made Hippo's breakout worth watching through the close?

The stock was moving sharply higher during the broadcast. Gatlin wanted it to retain that strength into the close, while DePablos used roughly $36 and the IPO-anchored average to assess the setup.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .