Takeaways

#
  • Baiynd found that the confidence and control she had as a business owner did not transfer directly to trading.
  • She shifted toward following established buying and selling while retaining the business discipline of controlling costs.
  • The hosts and guest discussed both the potential value and the limitations of structured trading evaluations.
  • More difficult intraday conditions led Baiynd to reduce position size and wait more patiently for entries.

Anne-Marie Baiynd came to trading with money earned from a successful recruiting business and an education in mathematics and statistics. Technical analysis looked logical. Working with data, largely on her own, also appealed to her after the demands of running a people-focused business.

The transition was much harder than she expected. In this Off The Charts conversation, recorded July 16, 2024 and published July 26, she told Steve Strazza and Sean McLaughlin that the confidence she had built as a business owner initially worked against her.

A business owner could influence more of the outcome

Baiynd described the habit of assuming she could enter a difficult situation and figure it out. In her company, she knew her strengths, understood the relationships and could influence decisions. That experience encouraged her to believe she could also work her way out of a losing trade.

The market did not offer the same control. Her early losses forced her to stop treating determination as a reason that price should eventually come back.

She kept one business discipline: controlling costs. But she changed how she looked for opportunities. Rather than trying to identify a top or bottom before everyone else, she wanted to become an early participant in a move that buyers and sellers were already establishing. Candlesticks helped her judge where price was holding and where participants were refusing to let it fall further.

Strazza described a successful business-owner friend whose confidence had become a liability in the market. Separately, he and Baiynd recalled their own painful early trading losses. Strazza explicitly said he would not recommend that others follow the same path.

Rules could help, but they could also be a poor fit

The conversation turned to futures-trader evaluation programs. Baiynd disclosed a longstanding involvement with Topstep and argued that a structured environment could help people learn to control position size and losses before risking a larger amount of personal capital.

McLaughlin had reservations about the wider industry. He described meeting people who kept paying evaluation subscriptions without reaching the point where they could earn money. He did not identify those providers, and his concern was whether the arrangement was helping those traders progress.

Baiynd emphasized the need to understand the rules and assess whether the permitted drawdown fit the person’s method. Someone repeatedly failing within those constraints might need a different framework or a change in behavior. McLaughlin agreed that the trader also had to examine why the same monthly expense kept recurring.

They did not resolve that debate into a single learning method. Strazza questioned whether externally imposed limits would have taught him to stop himself. Baiynd saw value in boundaries that prevented a new trader from repeatedly increasing risk.

She had already changed her size as conditions changed

Baiynd traded options, futures and options on futures. Her options activity included swing and shorter-term trades, while she generally closed futures positions each night because she preferred to sleep without that exposure.

She said the previous six months had brought intraday swings that shook her out of positions more often. Her response was to trade smaller and become more selective about entries. She wanted to wait for a formation that gave her an edge rather than chase a move simply because it was happening.

That adjustment mattered more to her than maintaining the same activity level. If a trade did not come to the area she wanted, she could leave it alone.

Sharing ideas helped her test her own thinking

Baiynd said writing about trades helped her organize her ideas. Stocktwits and other online discussions gave her a place to compare perspectives after an early experience of traders being reluctant to share what they knew. Disagreement could expose something her own assumptions had hidden.

Her enthusiasm for markets remained strong, but she also made room to disconnect. When McLaughlin worried about missing opportunities during an upcoming camping trip, she argued that taking the break could help him over the longer run. Other people would make trades while he was away. There would be new opportunities when he returned.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2024-07-26 episode.

What business habit did Baiynd have to change?

She had to stop assuming that determination and problem-solving would make a losing trade recover. Unlike her own company, the market was not an environment she could control.

Link to this answer

How had she adapted to intraday volatility?

She said she had reduced position size and become more selective about entry locations and formations, rather than chasing moves that did not fit her plan.

Link to this answer

Why did she value sharing and debating trade ideas?

Writing helped her organize her thinking, while discussion exposed perspectives her own assumptions might obscure. She described that exchange as useful even when she disagreed with an idea.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .