Takeaways
#- Marmanides would identify a price-and-volume move without inventing a news catalyst when he could not find one.
- He paired fast reporting with accuracy and clear treatment of unconfirmed information.
- A stock moving against the apparent meaning of its headlines was a reason to reassess the trade.
- During the early-August volatility, he said he reduced the information flow rather than repeating every negative comment.
Steve Strazza had a favorite kind of message from Milton Marmanides’s news desk: a stock or market was moving on heavy volume, but there was no news to explain it. For a service built around information, that absence could be useful information itself.
On Off the Charts, in an episode published August 23, 2024, Marmanides joined Strazza and Sean McLaughlin to discuss the judgment behind The Trade Exchange. He would report a move without inventing a catalyst to satisfy someone asking why it happened. Sometimes, he said, buyers were simply showing up.
Speed had to come with accuracy
McLaughlin asked which mattered more to a news trader: receiving information quickly or understanding its context. Marmanides put speed and accuracy together. A fast headline could still be misleading if it had been shortened in a way that changed its meaning.
He described checking what was circulating and distinguishing confirmed information from unconfirmed reports. If a rumor was already affecting a stock, he could acknowledge the report while making its uncertain status clear.
The desk also filtered aggressively. Marmanides estimated that he reviewed roughly 10,000 headlines in a day while passing along perhaps 60 or 70 specific items. His selection depended on whether the information was likely to matter to a stock or the broader market.
The reaction could contradict the headline
Strazza added a third consideration: price. A report that looked bad on paper could be followed by a rally, while seemingly strong news could lead to selling.
Marmanides said that still surprised him after years in the business. He wanted traders to consider whether the initial move had already occurred and what the market was doing next. Some fast traders could enter and exit before he finished announcing a headline. Others benefited from waiting long enough to understand the reaction.
McLaughlin posed the uncomfortable version of that problem: a trader was short, every headline appeared to support the position, and the stock kept rising. Marmanides’s response was to reassess the position when the stock stopped behaving as expected. More bearish commentary did not make the price move disappear.
During a selloff, he sometimes reduced the flow
The hosts used the early-August volatility as a case study. Marmanides recalled fielding calls offering many different explanations for the decline. In his interpretation, ordinary profit-taking had developed into a more forceful wave of selling as fear and competing narratives accumulated.
Asked how to handle that overload, he offered advice that might sound unusual from a news provider: sometimes step back from the news. He said he had roughly halved the amount of information he distributed during the volatile stretch because much of it repeated negative commentary.
That did not mean ignoring every event. He distinguished repetitive background headlines from developments involving a company central to market leadership. Nvidia (NVDA), with its forthcoming earnings report, was his example of news that could deserve close attention because of the role it had played in the advance.
He had moved from trading to providing information
Marmanides said his early trading had centered on technical analysis. Adding news and context helped him build conviction, and the cost and difficulty of obtaining useful information eventually gave him the idea for The Trade Exchange.
By the time of the interview, he said he no longer traded. He described a company rule against trading intended to avoid having subscribers wonder whether the desk was promoting its own positions.
Strazza remembered the early office, experiments with different formats and a technical-analysis book Marmanides had given him as he moved out of accounting. Marmanides recalled building software and the website on a tight budget, including overnight problems that required calls to developers abroad. Strazza had watched both the information service and his own approach to markets take shape there.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2024-08-23 episode.
Why was a “no news” message useful to Strazza?
It separated an observable move in price and volume from an unverified explanation. Marmanides could flag activity while being clear that he had not found a news catalyst.
How did Marmanides handle an unconfirmed report affecting a stock?
He described acknowledging that the report was circulating while identifying its uncertain status. Speed did not remove the need to check accuracy or preserve the meaning of the original information.
Why did he suggest stepping back from headlines during intense volatility?
He thought repeated commentary could overwhelm traders without improving their understanding. During the early-August selloff, he said he roughly halved his own news flow while continuing to distinguish potentially important developments from repetitive background noise.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .