Takeaways

#
  • McLaughlin sized the short puts around the potential stock assignment, not the premium received.
  • A high-probability options trade can still carry a much larger loss than its maximum gain.
  • He closed the losing position and reported a roughly 3.2% portfolio loss.

Sean McLaughlin's response to a large options loss began with a decision he made before entering the trade. In the conversation with Spencer Israel published October 27, he explained how position sizing kept a sharp decline in XP from becoming a much larger portfolio problem.

McLaughlin had sold November puts with a $26 strike. The trade expressed a view that the stock had room to fall before reaching that level. He collected $1.75 in premium, but the stock subsequently suffered a severe decline around Brazil's election. He said he paid $10.60 to close the puts.

A likely winner can still produce a large loss

McLaughlin described the trade-off in selling options: a relatively high probability of keeping the premium comes with a limited maximum gain and potentially much larger losses. The premium collected does not measure the full exposure.

For this short-put position, assignment could have required him to buy 100 shares at the strike price for each contract sold. His sizing method therefore began with the cost of owning the resulting shares, not with the smaller premium received.

He illustrated his own rule with a hypothetical $100,000 account. At a $26 strike, each contract could result in a $2,600 stock purchase. Keeping that potential stock position below 10% of the account would allow three contracts, rather than four. That was his risk framework for the example, not a universal allocation recommendation.

Closing the position

McLaughlin said the loss reduced his portfolio by approximately 3.2%. He did not minimize that result. He called it painful, but manageable enough to recover from. The distinction mattered: the individual position had been badly damaged, while the portfolio retained the capacity to continue.

He also chose to close the position instead of waiting and hoping for a rebound. A deeply in-the-money short put can bring assignment risk, and he discussed the implications for traders who did not want to own the shares or lacked sufficient buying power.

The episode is an account of a losing trade and the preparation behind it. McLaughlin's central point was that risk cannot be judged solely by the probability of success. The size and consequences of the less likely outcome also belong in the plan.

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .