Takeaways

#
  • Macke distinguished pressure from fuel costs from the blanket selling it could provoke in consumer stocks.
  • Best Buy's price recovery and AI-assisted shopping experience supported a company-specific case.
  • Macy's was a watchlist idea with a preferred entry near chart support, not a disclosed new holding.
  • Premium theaters and malls offered a shared thesis around a better social experience.

Jeff Macke could accept that rising gas prices were bad for consumers and still want to buy the stocks being punished for them. The question was whether the damage to a business justified the damage to its share price.

In this conversation with Spencer Israel, recorded September 16 and published September 18, Macke went looking for retailers and leisure businesses that were executing well despite an increasingly hostile backdrop. Higher fuel costs squeezed household budgets and raised the cost of moving merchandise. They also gave investors a compelling reason to sell the entire consumer category.

"The stock price is a function of the fundamentals and the narrative," Macke said. Both were under pressure when oil surged. His opportunity depended on that pressure easing before the businesses themselves deteriorated as much as their stocks suggested.

Best Buy had already found buyers

Best Buy stood out because it was trading near a 52-week high. Israel was surprised. Macke took that surprise as evidence of how little investors expected from the company.

The stock had recovered from a selloff around its earnings report. Macke was watching the round-number attraction of $100, but the more interesting part of his argument involved the experience of buying electronics.

He had recently used an AI chatbot to help select televisions, compare technical requirements and arrange a purchase. For a retailer selling products that customers find difficult to evaluate, that assistance could remove a meaningful obstacle. A customer might arrive at a decision without occupying a specialist in the store for an extended consultation.

Macke saw potential in combining that assistance with a familiar retailer, delivery and an aging installed base of televisions bought during the pandemic. He acknowledged uncertainty about exactly how Best Buy would monetize the change. His own purchases illustrated a possible improvement in shopping, not a measured company-wide earnings contribution.

Macy's required a different entry

Macy's was a less obvious candidate, including to Macke himself. He described a better quarter, positive comparable sales and valuable real estate, then contrasted those improvements with investors' fixation on fuel costs.

He was especially interested if the shares returned to roughly $17 to $18, where he saw chart support. That was a proposed entry area, not a declaration that he already owned every business on the screen. Israel explicitly framed the discussion as window shopping.

The timing mattered. A retailer could offer a substantial tactical move without becoming a five-year holding. Macke wanted the business to keep performing while the market gave him a price that reflected unusually bleak expectations.

A better night out was the theater thesis

Macke's interest in movie theaters went beyond a strong summer box office. He thought operators offering better seats, food and presentation had improved the reason to leave home.

The competition was a comfortable couch and a large television, including the ones he had just bought. A premium theater needed to deliver a social experience that home entertainment could not replicate. He pointed to IMAX, Marcus and Cinemark in that discussion, while Israel highlighted their pullbacks after strong advances.

Mall operators brought him to a similar argument. Consumers could shop online and still value going somewhere with other people. Macke thought investors were too quick to translate expensive gasoline into the end of that behavior, especially at properties serving affluent customers.

He still wanted a better price. "I want them to come in and get battered a little more," he said of the mall stocks. Across the watchlist, his method was consistent: find evidence that the business was holding up, identify the fear weighing on the shares, and let the entry price determine whether that disagreement was worth taking.

Questions and answers

#

From the September 18, 2026 conversation.

What made consumer stocks interesting to Macke despite rising fuel costs?

He looked for businesses executing better than their depressed share prices suggested. Higher fuel costs hurt customers and shipping economics, but also encouraged investors to sell the category broadly. His thesis depended on that pressure easing while the selected businesses continued to perform.

Link to this answer

What was Macke's business case for premium movie theaters?

Better seats, food and presentation could give customers a reason to leave a comfortable home setup. Macke focused on the social experience and operational improvements, not simply a strong summer box office. He still wanted an entry price that made the opportunity attractive.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .