Takeaways
#- Thompson’s September tally showed weak participation despite a relatively steady index.
- The largest companies and semiconductors remained constructive in his analysis.
- Seasonality supplied background support rather than a substitute for price confirmation.
- He was watching several oversold groups but had not entered the discussed recovery positions.
- Reclaimed levels and follow-through would determine whether breadth was improving.
Chapters
A flat index can conceal a difficult month for most of its stocks. In the Thompson's Two Cents presentation published October 4, Larry Thompson acknowledged that September's breadth was weak, then explained why he still saw reasons for optimism.
The two observations were not contradictory in his framework. Large companies could keep the index steady while many constituents declined. Investors did not have to deny the internal weakness to recognize that the market's most influential leaders remained strong.
Thompson's question was what might happen if those leaders kept working and some of the weaker groups began to recover.
Count the stocks, then look at their weight
Thompson showed his own tally of September's winners and losers. Roughly one in five S&P 500 constituents had risen, and many of the declines were substantial. Technology stood apart from most sectors in the share of stocks advancing.
That explained why the month could feel much worse to an investor holding laggards than to someone looking only at the index. It also left room for individual bearish trades even when shorting the broad market had been less productive.
Thompson objected to turning those observations into opposing identities. A permanently bullish commentator could dismiss the internal damage. A permanently bearish one could overlook the companies still carrying the index. Neither response required as much work as examining both.
His preferred interpretation kept the two facts together: leadership was narrow, but the leaders were important enough to matter.
The starters were still on the court
Thompson compared the market with the 1995–96 Chicago Bulls. A problem with a supporting player did not have the same consequence as losing the team's stars.
In the market version of that analogy, the largest stocks, the Nasdaq 100 and semiconductors were the key players. Their trends remained constructive in his analysis. That was his first reason to avoid assuming that weak participation had already doomed the index.
His second reason was seasonality. Thompson reviewed historical October results, the fourth quarter and midterm-year patterns. He treated those records as a favorable background for the period ahead, rather than a reason to ignore the actual charts.
The third reason was more conditional: weakness elsewhere had created potential recovery setups. If oversold groups turned upward while the leaders remained healthy, participation could improve instead of the index simply falling toward the laggards.
Oversold was a starting point, not an entry signal
Thompson walked through industrials, banks, materials, financials and home construction. Some charts were still ugly. He wanted reclaimed levels and follow-through before treating them as improving trades.
“I haven't put on any of these positions yet, but I'm looking,” he said during the financials discussion. A watchlist and an open position were different stages of the process.
The appeal of these setups was a nearby point at which the thesis would be wrong. Thompson discussed moving averages and horizontal levels as ways to structure that decision. His goal was to keep a failed recovery attempt from becoming a large, open-ended commitment.
“It's probabilistic business, not a deterministic business,” he said. He did not know whether an attempted reversal would develop into a major winner. He wanted a favorable combination of trend, background conditions and an identifiable exit.
Home construction was his more speculative example. A failed breakdown could create a forceful reversal, but he stressed the size of that if. He was looking for evidence, not assuming that a weak group had already bottomed.
Thompson's optimism therefore had a specific shape. Continue to recognize the strong leaders, look for improvement among the laggards, and distinguish a promising setup from a confirmed recovery. If breadth failed to join the leaders, the recovery trades would need to be reassessed.
Questions and answers
#From the October 4, 2026 conversation.
How could September feel weak when the index was relatively steady?
Many S&P 500 constituents declined while a smaller group of influential companies supported the index. Thompson distinguished the number of rising stocks from their index weights. Someone holding laggards could experience a much worse month than the headline index suggested.
What did Thompson need beyond an oversold reading before entering a recovery trade?
He wanted reclaimed levels and follow-through, with a nearby point that would invalidate the setup. His watchlist included weak sectors, but he distinguished watching from having a position. Favorable seasonality and strong leaders improved the background without proving that any individual recovery had begun.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .