Takeaways

#
  • Perz distinguished an expected rate hike from evidence that the commodity cycle had ended.
  • He watched the 30-year yield relative to the policy rate, then the dollar, for a change in conditions.
  • Latin American equity strength supported the thesis, while weaker regional currencies complicated it.
  • Copper's crowded positioning made the near-term setup less attractive despite its primary uptrend.
  • Grains, agriculture and sugar offered different stages of price strength.
Chapters
  1. Two possible bond-market responses
  2. The dollar as a second test
  3. Latin American leadership
  4. Copper positioning and currency weakness
  5. Grains and the agriculture breakout
  6. Soft commodities and shipping

Jason Perz and Sam Gatlin were expecting a Federal Reserve rate hike. They were not treating that expectation as an automatic reason to exit the commodity trade.

On the September 15 Supercycle Report Live, the two separated a widely anticipated announcement from the evidence that would show whether their market thesis had changed. Perz wanted to see how the 30-year Treasury yield behaved relative to the Fed's policy rate. Gatlin was watching leadership abroad, the currencies behind it and the increasingly different setups within commodities.

"The first hike doesn't end anything," Perz said. His argument was that the initial increase alone would not establish that the cycle had run its course. The market's response over the following days would matter more.

Watch the distance between rates

Perz described the gap between the policy rate and the long Treasury yield as open jaws. If the Fed raised its rate while the 30-year yield fell toward it, the gap would narrow. He would read that as evidence of tighter conditions and a changing outlook.

There was another possibility: long yields could continue rising despite the hike. That would tell a different story about inflation and the effectiveness of the initial policy move.

He did not want to make the entire judgment from the first minutes after the announcement. He specifically pointed to the following Monday and Tuesday as opportunities to assess a more settled response.

The dollar was his second test. He associated a narrowing rate gap and tighter conditions with potential dollar strength. Yet the leadership he was seeing in international and commodity-linked markets still looked consistent with his weaker-dollar thesis.

International leadership needed to persist

Brazil and other Latin American markets featured prominently in the relative-performance discussion. Perz saw that strength as part of the same broad environment supporting commodities.

He was willing to stay with that thesis through volatility, provided the leadership remained visible after the Fed meeting. That did not mean he wanted to make a large new international purchase immediately before the event. He wanted the subsequent rankings and charts to confirm that the same markets continued to lead.

Gatlin raised an important complication. Latin American currencies had recently weakened against the dollar and violated a trend line he was tracking. He was open to the move becoming a shakeout, but for the moment it added a reason for caution, particularly around copper.

Copper was strong, but crowded

Gatlin described speculative copper positioning as exceptionally heavy and pointed to repeated failed breakout attempts. The longer-term supply story and primary uptrend could be attractive while the immediate risk and reward were less favorable.

Perz agreed that crowding mattered without insisting that positioning had to return all the way to neutral. A strong trend could resume after a smaller reset. What he wanted was evidence in price, such as stabilization and a turn higher.

The reason to monitor positioning was the speed of a possible reversal. "It just means that the trade could turn pretty quickly, pretty violently," he said.

Their exchange preserved both sides of the copper case: a favorable longer horizon and a more difficult entry in the present setup.

Agriculture offered a different chart

Gatlin's equal-weight grains index had spent years consolidating after its 2022 peak. He now saw a breakout that could mark the start of a more sustained advance. The broader agricultural fund, DBA, gave him another way to examine strength beyond the grains alone.

They contrasted that agricultural strength with pressure on long Treasuries. In their framework, persistent inflation helped explain why bond prices remained weak even when parts of the market had moved sideways for an extended period.

Sugar also interested them after a breakout and continued price strength. Perz preferred the futures for expressing that view, while acknowledging that access and vehicle choice differed among investors. Other soft commodities had their own stages of recovery, rather than one identical setup.

Marine shipping rounded out the discussion as another area of strength in their portfolios. The larger message was selective persistence: keep the commodity thesis while the evidence supports it, recognize when an individual market becomes crowded, and let the dollar and long yields show whether the policy change has altered the environment.

Questions and answers

#

From the September 15, 2026 conversation.

Why wasn't the first rate hike an automatic exit signal for the commodity thesis?

Perz wanted to see how long yields, the dollar and international leadership behaved after the announcement. A narrowing gap between the policy rate and the long yield would mean something different from continued widening. The subsequent market response mattered more than the expected decision alone.

Link to this answer

How did crowded copper differ from the agricultural setup Gatlin described?

Copper retained a favorable longer-term trend but faced heavy speculative positioning and repeated failed breakouts. Gatlin's grains index, by contrast, was emerging from a multiyear consolidation. The discussion treated commodity markets separately, with different entry conditions even within a shared inflation thesis.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .