Takeaways

#
  • Gatlin remained constructive on energy while arguing that refining shares had become extended.
  • Refining stocks were making highs without confirmation from the crack spread in his analysis.
  • He favored moving some exposure toward oil and gas producers as crude strengthened relative to refined products.

Oil refiners had been some of the energy market's strongest performers when Sam Gatlin joined Spencer Israel for the episode published October 22. Gatlin's response was to take some gains and look elsewhere within energy.

That decision did not depend on calling an end to the industry's longer-term advance. Gatlin still saw a structural shortage of refining capacity. His concern was more immediate: share prices had run far above their longer-term averages while an important measure of refining profitability was weakening.

Share prices and margins were telling different stories

Refiners buy crude oil and turn it into products such as gasoline and diesel. The difference between the cost of that input and the value of the resulting products is central to the business. Gatlin used the crack spread to track those changing economics.

In the charts he discussed, refining stocks were reaching new highs without confirmation from the spread. Gasoline was weakening relative to crude, and heating oil was also losing relative momentum. If crude costs rise faster than the products a refiner sells, the margin picture can deteriorate even while energy prices remain firm.

That divergence mattered more to Gatlin because the stocks were already extended. He highlighted the distance between refining shares and their 200-day moving averages as a reason to consider how much favorable news the rally had already absorbed. A strong industry trend can continue while individual stocks experience a substantial correction.

A rotation within energy

Gatlin preferred shifting some exposure toward exploration and production companies, using the SPDR S&P Oil & Gas Exploration & Production ETF, XOP, as an example. His reasoning followed the same input-and-output relationship: crude outperforming refined products could favor producers relative to refiners.

He was making a relative allocation decision, not treating every part of energy as interchangeable. Refiners benefit from attractive processing margins; producers have more direct exposure to the commodities they extract. Those businesses can move differently even under the same sector label.

For Gatlin, taking profits allowed him to retain a constructive energy view while reducing exposure to a trade whose price gains had outpaced its margin signal. The evidence to revisit was whether refining margins recovered enough to support the stocks' next move.

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .