Takeaways
#- Dillian treated exceptional news attention as sentiment evidence and found it more useful at extremes than during ordinary trading.
- His long-term bullish gold view coexisted with short-term caution about an attention-grabbing price milestone.
- He used public reactions and trend-exhaustion tools while reducing opinion reading that was influencing his own judgment.
- He viewed introspection and emotional skill as parts of trading that could improve through experience.
Jared Dillian’s approach to trading began with how people felt about a market. He wanted to know when enthusiasm or fear had become unusually intense, and he used news coverage, social media and conversations to help locate those extremes.
In an Off The Charts interview published August 30, 2024, Sean McLaughlin and Steve Strazza asked him to expand on an essay written after the early-August volatility shock. The conversation also turned inward: reading other investors’ emotions, Dillian argued, required some understanding of his own.
News coverage mattered most at extremes
Dillian described himself as a sentiment trader. He was interested in the point at which a price move drew exceptional attention, whether the asset had risen dramatically or suffered a severe decline.
He did not frame journalists as foolish. Their job was to cover newsworthy events, and a market near an extreme was more likely to become a story than one moving quietly through the middle of a range. That made the coverage useful to him for a different reason than a reader looking for the next thing to buy.
His example was a report that a 400-ounce gold bar, at $2,500 an ounce, was worth $1 million. He remained a long-term gold bull, but saw the excitement around that milestone as a reason for short-term caution. The headline was evidence of attention at an elevated price, not an improvement in the metal itself.
He stressed that sentiment was most useful to his process at extremes. Ordinary, uneventful trading offered much less to work with.
Public reactions were another source of information
Twitter helped him observe the intensity of investors’ attachment to an asset. Dillian recalled the responses he received when criticizing Bitcoin: the volume and emotional force of the replies were information in their own right.
He also listened to people outside finance. When a stock became a recurring topic in ordinary conversation, that could help him judge how far enthusiasm had spread.
He combined those observations with technical tools aimed at identifying trend exhaustion, including DeMark indicators. His focus was on conditions that might precede a reversal, rather than using a trend-following system to remain with an established move.
That was a difficult way to trade, he acknowledged. A stock down sharply could continue falling. The price change alone did not establish that sentiment had reached the point he was looking for.
Persuasive commentary could obscure his own judgment
After starting his newsletter, Dillian initially subscribed to other investment publications and read widely. He found that strong arguments could become so persuasive that he began repeating them instead of forming an independent view.
He eventually reduced that kind of reading. He preferred reporting he could evaluate for sentiment information over opinion pieces that pulled his reasoning toward another writer’s conclusion.
The distinction concerned how he used the material. He was looking for evidence of what participants believed and how strongly they believed it, while trying to keep their conclusions separate from his own decisions.
Emotional skill took time to develop
Dillian identified experience, intelligence, emotional fitness and introspection as qualities he valued in a trader. Introspection meant examining the motives behind a decision, including why a position felt attractive or why a loss was difficult to accept.
He believed those skills could develop with experience. After arriving on Wall Street from the Coast Guard, he said it took roughly five years to become more comfortable taking trading risk. That was a change in his relationship with uncertainty, not simply learning how to place an order.
He did not expect most people to eliminate emotion. His argument was that recognizing and managing it was more realistic. Near the end of the interview, he connected that personal awareness back to his market process: understanding other people’s fear or enthusiasm was harder if he refused to acknowledge those feelings in himself.
Questions and answers
#Questions about Jared Dillian’s interview published August 30, 2024.
How did Dillian use financial journalism?
He watched for unusually newsworthy price extremes and the attention surrounding them. Rather than treating a prominent story as a buy signal, he considered what it revealed about prevailing enthusiasm or fear.
Why did he reduce his reading of investment opinions?
He found persuasive commentary influencing his thought process until he was repeating other writers’ conclusions. He preferred to use reporting as sentiment evidence while preserving his own judgment.
What did introspection mean in his trading process?
It meant examining why he wanted to take a trade and how his emotions affected that decision. He believed emotional skill could develop with experience and that understanding his own reactions helped him interpret other market participants.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .