Takeaways

#
  • Macke evaluated stores against their own promises, using repeated visits rather than a single encounter.
  • He contrasted Costco and TJX’s consistent experiences with the uncertainty he saw at Target.
  • On’s strong results did not remove his concerns about its chart and valuation.
  • He treated earnings-day rallies as evidence about the consumer while remaining selective about entry prices.

A disappointing encounter with one sales associate was not enough for Jeff Macke to short a retailer. He wanted a running record of how the business performed across visits, locations and changing customer expectations.

On November 12, 2025, Macke explained that approach to Spencer Israel after a shopping trip with Sean McLaughlin. The purpose was to see whether stores delivered what they promised, then connect those observations with financial results and price action.

His holiday-season review included companies doing well operationally whose stocks still looked difficult. A good shopping experience was evidence to examine, not a substitute for the rest of the investment case.

Match the scorecard to the retailer

At Gap, Macke wanted basics in the right sizes, merchandise in stock, an organized floor and helpful staff. Those were the things the business needed to deliver consistently.

He did not expect identical service from every retail format. At Macy's, his starting requirements were a clean, organized store with the expected products available. The standard had to fit what the company was offering its customers.

He preferred visiting different locations and observing them repeatedly. That helped him distinguish a persistent operating problem from one unpleasant interaction.

Inside a store, he also looked beyond the retailer's name to the brands creating activity. Were customers responding to denim? Which products were selling through? Was the store doing more than shoppers expected, or struggling to fulfill its own marketing promise?

Costco and TJX made consistency part of the appeal

Macke used Costco as an example of a business that repeatedly delivered the experience customers expected. The assortment could change, but the value proposition and the reason to visit remained recognizable.

TJX supplied a related example through off-price apparel. Macke described the occasional unusually good bargain as a reward for continuing to look. That sense of discovery helped sustain the shopping experience.

He contrasted both businesses with Target, which he thought had become less clear about what it offered. The comparison was about execution against expectations, not whether every store needed to copy the same model.

Best Buy was another name he discussed publicly from his holiday research. He thought its in-store experience was better than many people expected. He also continued to like TJX's established performance, combining turnaround possibilities with businesses already delivering consistently.

On's quarter did not erase the chart problem

Macke praised On's reported results and its progress beyond footwear into apparel. But he was reluctant to chase the stock's large earnings-day rise.

He pointed to earlier strong reports that had also produced rallies without solving the shares' longer-running difficulties. Spencer noted that the latest move had already retreated from its opening strength.

Macke wanted three things to align: the financial performance, the stock's technical condition and a convincing account of what would drive the next stage of growth. In his view, On had not yet brought all three together at an attractive price.

That distinction also shaped his answer about Deckers. He saw a better business than its stock performance might suggest, but did not think a low earnings multiple alone resolved the growth and competitive questions. Concerns about Nike's efforts to reclaim shelf space remained part of the backdrop he was evaluating.

A strong report could be information without being an entry

The RealReal had also rallied sharply after earnings. Macke thought the resale business had become more substantial than the market's old image of a pandemic-era speculative company, and he saw short positioning contributing to the reaction.

He still cautioned against chasing a stock immediately after a large one-day move. The report could tell him something encouraging about demand without offering a favorable entry at that moment.

That was the approach he carried into the following week's retail reports. With government data disrupted, he expected Walmart and other major chains to provide useful evidence about prices, spending and the holiday outlook.

He wanted to compare what shoppers were buying with what stores were reporting. Repeated visits supplied one part of that work; earnings and the stock chart supplied the rest.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-11-12 episode.

What did Macke look for when visiting a store?

He checked staffing, organization, stock availability and whether the experience matched the retailer’s promise. He also watched which brands attracted customers and repeated the exercise across locations.

Link to this answer

Why was he cautious about On after strong earnings?

He had seen earlier strong quarters produce rallies that did not last. He wanted the financial results, chart and growth narrative to align rather than chase another large earnings-day move.

Link to this answer

How did he use a retailer’s earnings reaction?

The results and price response helped him judge demand and expectations. A positive report did not automatically justify buying after a sharp one-day rally.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .