Takeaways
#- Macke saw On’s growth as evidence that consumer demand differed substantially across retailers.
- He was concerned that strong reports earned modest gains while less impressive reports faced much larger declines.
- He wanted a concrete turnaround argument from Target and better price action before buying falling retail stocks.
- Nike and Starbucks interested him because their stocks were showing resilience despite familiar business risks.
Jeff Macke did not think the early retail earnings reports told one simple story about a failing consumer. On was selling expensive footwear and apparel at a rapid pace. Target and Best Buy were meeting a much harsher reception in the stock market.
Speaking with Spencer Israel on March 4, 2025, Macke focused on the distance between business performance and the price investors were willing to pay for it. Strong execution was still visible in retail. In that session, it was offering limited protection from selling.
On’s growth met a restrained market response
Macke highlighted roughly 36% revenue growth and 77% apparel growth at On, arguing that demand for its premium products challenged the claim that consumers were uniformly in trouble. The company’s fourth-quarter release put those reported growth rates at 35.7% and 77.5%, respectively.
He also admired the business’s margins and execution. Yet the share-price reaction disappointed him. After a sharp decline into the report, he saw a gain of only about 4%–5% during the discussion. He thought a strong report following that kind of selloff should have produced a more forceful response.
Valuation remained a legitimate objection; he was not calling the stock cheap merely because the business was growing. His concern was the asymmetry of the market’s reactions. Good news was earning a modest reward while ordinary disappointments were receiving much larger punishments.
Target needed a reason for investors to return
Macke described Target’s results as familiar rather than surprising. What troubled him was the caution accompanying them and the stock’s continued deterioration. During the broadcast, he pointed to new 52-week lows and a decline of roughly 5%–6%.
He was impatient with explanations centered on weather and the economy. He wanted management to show how Target could improve the business despite those conditions. A prospective buyer needed something concrete to support a turnaround, rather than another account of external pressures.
That criticism came despite his personal attachment to the company. He wanted Target to succeed, but the stock and operating narrative had not given him the evidence he wanted.
He also watched Target for clues about adjacent consumer categories. Stronger health-and-beauty performance, for example, could have helped him assess the selloff in companies such as e.l.f. Beauty. He was still waiting for a more encouraging signal.
Best Buy and Abercrombie showed the cost of weak reactions
Best Buy’s report did not strike Macke as disastrous. He described its computer business as acceptable and weakness in midrange televisions as unsurprising. The stock’s sharp decline nevertheless showed how little tolerance investors had for the outlook.
Abercrombie & Fitch presented a related problem ahead of its report. He respected its execution and the business improvement behind its earlier advance. A much lower share price did not persuade him to step in front of a chart that kept falling.
His reluctance came from the selling itself, rather than a claim that those businesses had stopped functioning. He wanted to see how the market received the next information before treating the declines as opportunities.
Nike and Starbucks were resisting their bad news
Macke was more interested in the resilience developing in Nike and Starbucks. Both had suffered brand and operating difficulties, and both faced international exposures that looked uncomfortable amid the tariff debate. Their stocks were beginning to act better despite those concerns.
He saw that response as a possible reversal. For Starbucks, he also offered a simple way to follow the operating effort: visit a store and observe whether the coffee arrived within the four-minute goal he described. It was a tangible test of execution that he could revisit alongside the chart.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-03-04 episode.
Why did On’s report matter to Macke?
Its rapid footwear and apparel growth showed demand for premium products, challenging a blanket claim that all consumers were retrenching. He still thought the stock’s response was weak relative to the results.
Why was he reluctant to buy Abercrombie after its decline?
He respected the company’s execution but did not want to buy into a chart that continued falling. A lower share price alone had not changed that judgment.
What attracted him to Nike and Starbucks?
Their stocks were beginning to resist bad news despite operating challenges and international exposure. Macke viewed that resilience as a possible trend reversal.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .