Takeaways
#- Macke connected Ollie’s and TJX’s resilience to opportunistic buying and the ability to vary their merchandise.
- He disclosed holding Costco, Walmart and BJ’s; a possible Walmart hedge was still only a consideration.
- He respected Best Buy’s management but questioned the replacement cycle, while Target faced difficult discretionary-inventory decisions.
- Fall and holiday ordering deadlines made the duration of uncertainty important, even before the selling seasons arrived.
Jeff Macke’s retail comparison on April 22, 2025 started with a buying problem. Companies needed to plan merchandise for seasons still months away while the terms of importing it remained uncertain. The stocks he preferred had ways to absorb that uncertainty: flexible purchasing, substantial financial resources or a business customers already trusted.
With Spencer Israel, Macke examined why Ollie’s Bargain Outlet and TJX were holding up, why he still owned Costco, Walmart and BJ’s Wholesale Club, and why a falling share price was not enough to make a struggling retailer attractive.
Ollie’s and TJX could change what they bought
The charts of Ollie’s and TJX stood out against the weakness elsewhere in retail. Macke connected that strength to opportunistic buying. A retailer built around finding available bargains did not have to keep offering precisely the same merchandise on every visit.
He described TJX’s appeal as a treasure hunt. Customers could trade down without feeling that the shopping experience had lost its interest. Ollie’s offered a deeper-discount version of opportunistic merchandise buying. In his view, that flexibility was useful when conventional inventory planning had become difficult.
The comparison was about how the businesses bought and sold goods. Macke did not provide a specific TJX entry price when Israel returned to that question near the end of the episode. The positive business assessment remained separate from an agreed price for a new trade.
He owned Costco, Walmart and BJ’s for different reasons
Israel raised the high valuations of Costco and Walmart and asked why BJ’s received less attention. Macke pointed partly to BJ’s regional footprint. It was less familiar to investors who did not encounter its stores, even though he liked what he saw in the business.
Costco and Walmart had another advantage in his assessment: resources. He thought they could spend money solving problems and withstand disruption longer than weaker competitors. Their expensive stocks made the holding decision uncomfortable, but did not erase that operating advantage.
Macke disclosed that he was long all three. He was reluctant to sell Costco and Walmart, and said he could imagine hedging Walmart. He had not reported putting that hedge on. BJ’s was the name he was more comfortable considering as a purchase at the time.
Israel’s position was different. He had sold a small Costco holding about a month earlier and regretted it. That exchange captured the difficulty of the valuation question: recognizing that a business was strong did not make its stock feel inexpensive.
Best Buy and Target had harder inventory questions
Macke spoke favorably about Best Buy’s management while questioning the demand cycle it faced. Televisions bought during the pandemic did not necessarily need replacing soon. New gaming systems or phones could help, but the company still needed the right merchandise, at a workable cost, when customers wanted it.
For Target, he emphasized discretionary goods and private-label merchandise as important parts of its appeal and profitability. Uncertainty over sourcing and costs therefore reached into the assortment that distinguished the business.
He explicitly said he did not know what Target had done in response. His concern was the planning problem, not a report of a confirmed company decision. A relative-value trade he might ordinarily consider, buying Target against a short position in Walmart, did not appeal to him in that environment.
That was the distinction between a low valuation and a workable thesis. The weaker stock still needed a business path that made its apparent discount useful.
Seasonal orders could not wait indefinitely
Dick’s Sporting Goods provided a more concrete example of the calendar problem. Macke respected the company, but worried about both the cost of imported merchandise and discretionary demand. Goods for the fall sports season had to be planned well before customers walked in to buy them.
Waiting for clarity might reduce the chance of committing at an unfavorable cost. Waiting too long could interfere with the season the inventory was meant to serve. That tension also applied to holiday merchandise, which was already becoming a spring purchasing decision.
Macke wanted the coming earnings reports to reveal how companies were handling those commitments. He expected some management teams to struggle with guidance, but the reports had not yet supplied the answers. His preference for flexible buyers and well-resourced operators rested on that unresolved operating problem.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-04-22 episode.
Why did Macke like Ollie’s and TJX’s position?
He emphasized opportunistic purchasing and flexible assortments. Those businesses could find available bargains rather than depend on carrying precisely the same merchandise every visit.
Which large retailers did he say he owned?
Macke disclosed long positions in Costco, Walmart and BJ’s. He considered the first two expensive but well resourced, and was more comfortable discussing BJ’s as a purchase at the time.
Why did the inventory calendar matter in April?
Retailers needed to place orders ahead of fall sports, back-to-school and holiday demand. Macke worried that continued uncertainty would make those commitments harder, and wanted earnings reports to explain companies’ responses.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .