Takeaways

#
  • Macke saw recovering retail charts as a reason to question the scale of consumer pessimism.
  • He wanted companies to explain whether tariff costs were being absorbed, negotiated with suppliers or passed to shoppers.
  • Walmart and Target offered different tests because their scale, supplier leverage and merchandising positions differed.
  • He also watched Home Depot, Toll Brothers and Abercrombie for evidence that improving stock prices had support in the business.

Jeff Macke saw a problem with the bleak consumer story circulating in August 2025: several retail stocks were behaving better than that story suggested. In the August 12 Retail Roundup with Spencer Israel, he pointed to recovering charts and an inflation report that had not delivered the broad shock many investors feared.

He was not claiming that every price category was calm. Rent, furniture and electronics remained part of the discussion. His question was whether the evidence justified the scale of pessimism surrounding consumer businesses, especially as a concentrated run of retail earnings approached.

Tariff costs had to land somewhere

Macke framed the tariff problem through the choices available to a retailer. A company could absorb the cost in its own margin, negotiate a lower purchase price from suppliers or charge shoppers more. Those choices could also be combined across products.

He wanted to look past the language companies used to describe that work. “Mitigation” might mean a successful supplier negotiation, a price increase or another operational adjustment. The word alone did not reveal what had happened to demand or profitability.

The bearish argument still had a timetable. Macke described the view that earlier inventory purchases and delayed tariff effects could postpone the inflation impact. A relatively benign report in August would not settle what appeared in subsequent months. For the immediate trading decisions, however, he continued to give weight to the prices and results already available.

Walmart’s scale made its report a useful test

Macke was particularly interested in Walmart’s coming report. Its sales volume and range of customers gave him a direct view into spending that he considered more useful than another abstract forecast about the consumer.

Amazon had already raised his expectations. He emphasized its retail operations, including both its own sales and third-party activity, rather than treating it solely as a cloud or AI business. He read its reported demand and limited need for broad price increases as evidence against a simple consumer-collapse thesis.

Walmart’s chart was also approaching a point where further gains would look like a breakout. Macke acknowledged that the stock was expensive. He nevertheless wanted the earnings report to test whether the business could support the price action.

Target faced a different version of the same problem

Target was due to report immediately before Walmart. Macke did not put it in the same competitive position as Walmart, Amazon or Costco. In his view, it had less leverage over suppliers and had not merchandised strongly enough to raise prices without threatening demand.

That made the report especially informative. He wanted to hear whether comparable-store sales were improving and how the company was handling tariff costs. A discussion dominated by mitigation plans would be less convincing than evidence that the operation was already managing them well.

Yet Target’s shares had recovered above $100. Macke found that interesting precisely because his view of the stores remained skeptical. The stock could be anticipating improvement, a change in leadership or simply less damage than investors had priced in. The coming report would provide a firmer basis for judging those possibilities.

Housing and apparel offered more places to check

Home Depot and Toll Brothers were high on his watchlist. Their shares were recovering, and he wanted to hear whether management commentary could support the emerging optimism around housing-related spending. He would regard a more enthusiastic Home Depot outlook as a meaningful change from its recent tone.

Abercrombie & Fitch supplied another example of a stock recovering after a severe decline. Its previous earnings rally had failed quickly, but the shares were approaching the $100 area again. Macke believed the company had improved during its earlier run even though momentum had also carried the price too far.

He contrasted weak retailers with better operators such as On Holding. Consumers were still spending where they found value and wanted to shop. As the reports arrived, he wanted to separate companies earning that spending from those relying on a difficult economic backdrop to explain their own problems.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-08-12 episode.

What did Macke want to hear behind the word mitigation?

He wanted the practical detail: whether the retailer had negotiated lower supplier prices, raised selling prices or absorbed costs itself, and what those choices meant for margins and demand.

Link to this answer

Why did he treat Target differently from Walmart?

He believed Target had less supplier leverage and weaker merchandising, making it harder to offset tariffs or pass costs to shoppers. That made its comparable-store sales and cost commentary particularly useful.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .