Takeaways
#- Macke wanted positive U.S. comparable sales as evidence that Starbucks was winning customers back.
- He suspected short-covering pressure behind the Kohl's jump and separated that trading risk from the state of the stores.
- He viewed Lululemon's competitive and pricing pressures as company-specific problems that still needed attention.
- His Guess comparison showed why a surviving retail brand might spend years below its former peak without delivering a convincing recovery.
Starbucks was trying to improve its stores, Kohl's was surging and Lululemon had received another downgrade. Jeff Macke saw three different stock stories on July 22, 2025, but he wanted the same basic question answered: was the underlying retailer becoming more attractive to customers?
Speaking with Spencer Israel on Macke's Retail Roundup, he was skeptical that the recent price action supplied that answer. He wanted clearer operating progress from Starbucks, treated the Kohl's jump as a possible short squeeze and thought Lululemon still had company-specific problems to address.
Starbucks needed customers to return
Macke thought Brian Niccol was taking sensible steps at Starbucks. The food and the customer experience had improved in his assessment, but the scale of the chain made a turnaround difficult.
He was approaching the point at which he normally expected a new chief executive's initial plans to produce visible results. His expectations for the upcoming report were low. He wanted positive comparable sales in the United States as evidence that customers were returning, and he did not expect Starbucks to deliver them yet.
The concern was partly about a lost habit. Starbucks was trying to make the coffeehouse a place where people wanted to stay again, after changes that Macke believed had pushed some of those customers away. Restoring the setting would not necessarily restore their behavior immediately.
Israel noted that the shares had risen with much of the market since the spring. Macke acknowledged the more optimistic interpretation of the chart, but still wanted better earnings and customer demand to support it. The valuation left him uncomfortable with a business that was not yet showing the growth he wanted.
Kohl's rally raised a different risk for short sellers
Israel initially assumed the sharp move in Kohl's meant someone had agreed to buy the company. That was not the explanation they had found during the show.
Macke suspected a short squeeze. They were looking at a heavily shorted retailer that had already suffered a substantial multiyear decline. The combination could leave bearish traders exposed to a sudden rally even if the stores had not become more compelling.
Neither identified a clear operating improvement that explained the move. Macke's point was that a weak business did not make every short entry attractive. A chain could remain in difficulty for a long time without disappearing, while a crowded bearish position could become uncomfortable much faster.
The rally had also spread to other retail names, including Macy's and Best Buy. Israel saw that activity as part of the speculative energy in the broader market. Macke remained focused on separating the trading pressure from evidence of a healthier retailer.
Lululemon had more than an economic problem
Macke had been enthusiastic about Lululemon during its earlier growth. He credited the brand with helping change what men could comfortably wear, but the category had become much more competitive.
His concern was that Lululemon still regarded itself as a full-price brand while customers had more alternatives. He pointed to competition from Vuori and Alo and to greater clearance activity. He viewed those pressures as specific to the company, rather than something that could be explained entirely by the economy.
The downgrade discussed that morning had arrived after a large stock decline. Israel and Macke recognized that the timing could look late. Macke nevertheless thought the underlying question remained unresolved: where was the evidence that the earnings and the turnaround were improving?
He did not rule out a recovery. He argued that the company had problems it had not yet adequately addressed, and that a lower share price alone did not demonstrate that the work was finished.
Guess illustrated how long a former favorite could drift
Macke brought up a long-term Guess chart to show what could happen after a specialty retailer's strongest years. A brand could survive for decades without recapturing the popularity or shareholder returns of its earlier peak.
He also acknowledged that brands could become fashionable again, using Abercrombie as an example. He regarded that outcome as difficult to count on, rather than a reason to assume every established retailer would recover.
For Lululemon, that left him willing to step aside without taking a short position. Retail would keep producing new favorites. He wanted evidence that a company was earning renewed customer interest before treating its past success as a reason to own it again.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-07-22 episode.
What did Macke want to see from Starbucks?
He wanted positive U.S. comparable sales and stronger earnings as evidence that improvements to the food and store experience were bringing customers back. He entered the upcoming report with low expectations.
Did the Kohl's rally change his view of the business?
He did not identify a clear operating improvement during the discussion. He suspected a short squeeze and emphasized the risk of maintaining a crowded bearish position after an already substantial decline.
Was Macke recommending a short in Lululemon?
He said he was willing to walk away rather than remain short. His concern was the lack of evidence that the company's competitive and earnings problems were being resolved.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .