Takeaways
#- Macke saw the tariff reprieve as a chance for retailers to resume inventory decisions, even at lower margins.
- He expected businesses with more financial flexibility to handle the remaining pressure better.
- Gap’s operating turnaround and On’s relative price response interested him, while Topgolf and Kohl’s still raised separate concerns.
- He preferred Starbucks’ potential recovery response to Amazon’s more defensive competitive position in the scenario discussed.
Jeff Macke’s enthusiasm for the retail rally came down to a practical question: could companies buy the merchandise they needed to sell? On May 13, 2025, he thought the newly announced U.S.-China tariff reprieve had made that decision much easier.
Speaking with Spencer Israel, Macke described a market recovering from expectations of severe disruption. Companies could still face higher costs and weaker margins. But he believed investors had been preparing for something worse, including inventory shortages and businesses unable to keep operating normally.
A temporary opening for inventory decisions
The May 12 U.S.-China joint statement set out temporary reductions in recently escalated tariffs, including a 90-day suspension of specified increases. It did not remove every tariff or settle the longer negotiation.
For Macke, the immediate benefit was time. Retailers could make purchasing decisions, adjust supply chains and prepare for the holiday season with more room to operate. He was especially concerned with China because of its importance to merchandise sourcing.
He described the earlier problem as a shortage of workable choices. A retailer had a limited inventory budget, uncertain import costs and products it still needed to put on shelves. Delaying orders could create another problem later, even if management was trying to protect cash.
Buying at a lower margin was therefore an improvement over being unable to buy economically at all. Macke expected larger, better-funded businesses to withstand the pressure more easily. He remained concerned about smaller companies with less financial flexibility.
Gap could return to its turnaround story
Gap (GAP) illustrated the change he wanted investors to consider. Macke argued that its work diversifying sourcing had been overwhelmed by the earlier tariff shock. With some pressure easing, he could return to assessing the retailer’s operating turnaround.
He was prepared to tolerate near-term earnings damage from interrupted orders and more expensive shipping. That was his judgment about how to interpret a possible warning, rather than a forecast that the company would avoid one.
On Holding (ONON) was another example. Macke said he had bought it the previous day because it had not already made the same sharp move as other stocks reacting to the news. He thought its position had improved, and that investors with too little retail exposure were now chasing the recovery.
Financially strained companies still had problems
Macke did not extend that optimism to every business. Topgolf Callaway Brands (MODG) remained a concern because the golf-entertainment operation faced discretionary spending pressure. He preferred the idea of a simpler Callaway equipment business and was skeptical about what the company could obtain for Topgolf.
The company’s May 12 release still described the separation as planned. Macke’s preference for owning a stripped-down business was prospective.
Kohl’s (KSS) raised another question: access to financing. Easier inventory purchasing would help, but he remained uncertain whether the retailer could secure the funding it needed. A broad rally did not resolve that concern.
Starbucks and Amazon offered different exposures
Asked where he would add Amazon (AMZN), Macke suggested waiting for a pullback toward roughly $200. He liked the business, but thought Starbucks (SBUX) offered more recovery potential in the improving environment he was describing.
His reasoning was comparative. Amazon’s scale could help it gain ground when competitors struggled. A healthier retail economy might give those competitors more room to recover, while Starbucks could respond quickly to better conditions and cheaper funding.
Macke preferred Starbucks in that scenario. He was choosing between businesses with different sensitivities to the recovery, even as both benefited from a less threatening market backdrop.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2025-05-13 episode.
Why could retail stocks rise while costs remained elevated?
Macke thought investors had priced in severe disruption. A window to order inventory and keep shelves stocked was an improvement, even if companies still absorbed higher costs.
Why did he remain cautious about Kohl’s?
He was uncertain about its ability to secure financing. Being able to order merchandise did not by itself solve the company’s funding problem.
Why did he favor Starbucks over Amazon in an improving economy?
He thought Starbucks could recover quickly with better economic conditions and cheaper funding. Amazon’s ability to compete during severe disruption made it a different kind of exposure.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .