Takeaways

#
  • Macke saw retailers finding buyers after disappointing updates, a more constructive response than he would have expected earlier in the year.
  • He still saw declining earnings and policy uncertainty as risks to the recovery.
  • Costco's membership model and purchasing flexibility appealed to him, while its high valuation remained a concern.
  • He wanted Dick's to explain the operating case for Foot Locker and treated Macy's deal potential as a speculative possibility.

Retail stocks were giving Jeff Macke a reason to resist a broadly bearish view. Companies could deliver disappointing updates, trade lower initially and still find buyers. On May 27, 2025, he thought that response mattered as another busy week of earnings approached.

Speaking with Spencer Israel on Macke's Retail Roundup Live, he pointed to Williams-Sonoma, AutoZone, Target and American Eagle Outfitters. Their problems differed, but he saw their shares recovering from earnings-related weakness. The market was absorbing news that might have drawn a harsher response a few months earlier.

Better reactions did not erase the earnings problem

Macke also noted that XRT, the SPDR S&P Retail ETF, had recovered above its 200-day moving average while remaining below its recent highs. He took that as part of a constructive change in the sector's behavior.

He preferred listening to companies' earnings discussions over relying entirely on sentiment surveys. In the calls he had followed, retailers appeared better prepared to adapt their sourcing and operations than they had been during the pandemic disruptions. Easing trade-war tensions had also reduced some of his immediate concerns about supply.

His bearish case was straightforward, however: earnings expectations were still falling, and operating pressure could continue for several quarters. Lower profits made the same share price more expensive. Sudden policy headlines could also unsettle a market that had only recently begun recovering.

That left him constructive on the response to news without treating every retailer as an attractive purchase. The next reports would provide more information about which companies were adapting successfully.

Costco's advantages came with a demanding valuation

Both Macke and Israel disclosed owning Costco. Macke valued its membership model, loyal customers and flexibility in what it bought. He thought those features gave it resources and room to maneuver when the retail environment became more difficult.

For the forthcoming report, he wanted to hear about customer traffic and how management was handling trade uncertainty. Strong recent sales had raised expectations. He thought Costco's opportunistic buying model gave it more flexibility than a retailer committed to filling particular categories in fixed proportions.

He also described the stock as expensive. His affection for the company and reluctance to sell an existing holding did not remove that valuation concern. Costco was his example of a business he liked whose price already reflected considerable confidence.

Dick's needed to explain what Foot Locker added

Dick's Sporting Goods presented a different question. It had agreed to acquire Foot Locker, and Macke wanted a clearer explanation of the growth opportunity and how management would improve the acquired business.

He respected Dick's management and its success with large sporting-goods stores. That made capital allocation, rather than the purchase price alone, the central issue for him. Why was deeper exposure to footwear the best next use of the company's resources?

He wanted the upcoming earnings discussion to address operating improvements and efficiencies. General assurances about welcoming Foot Locker were not enough to answer those questions.

Macy's was a speculative deal idea

Macke had much less confidence in Macy's underlying department-store business. His interest was in what a buyer might do with assets such as Bluemercury and the company's properties, rather than a fresh endorsement of the existing operating plan.

The Foot Locker agreement made him consider whether buyers might look again at other struggling retailers. He speculated that even a willingness to revisit strategic alternatives could lift Macy's shares.

He did not expect that announcement as a likely outcome. He described the idea as a lottery ticket: a possible trade on corporate action, distinct from buying a business he wanted to own for its operating performance. No new Macy's purchase was disclosed in the discussion.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2025-05-27 episode.

Why did Macke focus on the reaction to disappointing retail updates?

He saw shares finding buyers after initial weakness, suggesting the market was absorbing bad news more readily. He considered that constructive even while earnings expectations remained under pressure.

Link to this answer

What did he want to hear from Dick's management?

He wanted to understand why Foot Locker was the best growth opportunity and how Dick's would improve its operations. A low purchase price and friendly assurances did not fully answer his capital-allocation questions.

Link to this answer

Why did he call the Macy's idea a lottery ticket?

The case depended on possible corporate action, such as reconsidering strategic alternatives, rather than confidence in the department-store business. He said such an announcement probably would not happen, so he treated it as speculation.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .