Takeaways
#- Macke thought concrete reports of tariff disruption could be less frightening than the severe outcomes investors had imagined.
- Under Armour’s low expectations interested him, but past disappointments kept him from buying.
- He disclosed a small personal On position and wanted a portfolio position, with earnings still ahead.
- He remained long Walmart while questioning how much of its operating strength was already reflected in the valuation.
Jeff Macke was becoming more optimistic about retailers as companies described how they were handling supply-chain disruption. Expectations had fallen far enough, he argued, that results short of a disaster could be received well.
That did not make every inexpensive stock appealing or every strong company worth chasing. In the May 9, 2025 Retail Roundup with Spencer Israel, Macke’s enthusiasm for On Holding differed sharply from his hesitation about Under Armour and his valuation concerns about Walmart.
Results were replacing the worst assumptions
Macke thought the experience of the pandemic had helped consumer companies prepare for another disruption. They were adjusting supply chains and beginning to quantify the damage. He expected concrete estimates to be less frightening than the prospect of commerce freezing altogether.
Peloton Interactive (PTON) was one example. Macke had wanted to see whether customers would keep their subscriptions, and he was encouraged by the retention figures. He thought that willingness to continue paying gave him useful information about the company’s customer base, even as the stock traded lower.
He still acknowledged the possibility of further tariff damage. His argument was about the gap between the outcomes investors had feared and what companies were reporting, not a prediction that every retailer would escape the disruption.
Under Armour looked cheap, but he remained reluctant
Israel introduced Under Armour as the first stock he had bought, back in 2015. The long-term chart gave them a reminder of how badly a popular growth story could disappoint.
Macke saw reasons a speculative buyer might take interest. He described low expectations, better liquidity than the company had had at other points and less direct exposure to China than some competitors. A business priced for a very poor outcome did not need everything to go right to attract buyers.
He nevertheless could not bring himself to buy. Past disappointments and doubts about management’s decisions outweighed the apparent bargain for him. Israel was more interested in seeing what would happen if the next report exceeded those depressed expectations.
On had the customer momentum he wanted
On Holding (ONON) drew a different response. Macke thought its shoes were moving beyond an initial customer group and becoming popular with teenagers as well. That wider appeal was central to his interest in the brand.
He also liked its international business and what he considered a diversified supply chain. But his strongest argument was market-share growth: a company winning customers could still grow even when the broader consumer environment weakened.
Macke disclosed a small personal position. He wanted to add the stock to the portfolio he discussed, but was still looking ahead to the following week’s earnings. His enthusiasm had not become an announced portfolio purchase.
Israel pointed to the company’s Swiss base and the strength of international stocks. Macke continued to favor the business, while recognizing that the stock’s performance and the company’s progress were separate questions.
Walmart’s strength came with a demanding price
Macke was already long Walmart (WMT). He valued its scale, store execution, inventory management and ability to invest in online operations. He also saw advertising as an important part of its business.
His concern was how much investors were paying for those advantages. He thought the share price had risen faster than earnings, expanding the valuation multiple. A mature retailer would need more earnings growth to sustain that higher price over time.
That made the coming report useful for two reasons. Walmart’s broad customer reach could show how consumers were behaving, and its own results would help investors judge whether its operational progress justified the stock’s valuation. Macke remained a shareholder, but described his position with considerably less enthusiasm than his interest in On.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2025-05-09 episode.
Why did Macke prefer On to Under Armour?
He saw On attracting customers across more age groups and gaining market share. Under Armour looked inexpensive to him, but his concerns about its history and decision-making kept him from buying.
What had he already bought in On?
Macke disclosed a small personal position. He wanted to add On to the portfolio he discussed, but had not announced that purchase and was still awaiting the upcoming earnings report.
What concerned him about Walmart despite owning it?
He thought the stock’s rise had expanded its valuation faster than earnings had grown. He liked the business but wanted stronger earnings progress to support the higher price investors were paying.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .