Takeaways

#
  • Macke’s favorable Amazon assessment came with a disclosed long position and questions about slower third-party seller growth.
  • He argued that Amazon’s service businesses still depended on the health of merchants and cloud customers.
  • Apple’s additional $100 billion repurchase authorization fit Macke’s preference for returning cash while supporting its core products.
  • The panel left tariff-related demand, Apple’s outlook and the next trading session’s reaction unresolved.

Amazon’s earnings were already out when Jeff Macke, Steve Strazza and Spencer Israel began their May 1, 2025 discussion. Apple’s report arrived while they were on air. Both companies had produced results that Macke broadly liked, yet their shares initially traded lower. The question was whether good earnings could finally draw a sustained positive response from investors.

Macke disclosed that he was long Amazon and gave its report a favorable initial assessment. His interest went beyond that quarter’s headline results. He wanted to understand how tariffs and weaker customers might affect the businesses that had made Amazon more profitable.

Amazon’s customers were part of its risk

Macke focused on slower growth among third-party sellers. Those merchants brought Amazon revenue from services such as fulfillment, making their financial health relevant even if Amazon itself continued gaining market share. A slowdown in that part of the business raised a question for him: was it an early warning about the broader economy?

China complicated the picture. The panel discussed Amazon’s exposure to Chinese sellers and the uncertainty surrounding their costs under the tariff regime. Macke was not arguing that Amazon’s logistics network had suddenly lost its value. He admired the money and effort required to build it. His concern was that the company’s advantages depended partly on other businesses remaining healthy enough to use its services.

He extended that reasoning to cloud computing. A deeper recession could hurt business customers even if Amazon remained competitive. A company could take share while the market around it weakened, leaving investors to weigh relative success against a tougher operating environment.

A change in market reaction

Strazza pressed Macke on what he meant by the market having turned a corner. Was he describing the companies’ fundamentals or the way investors responded to their results? Macke clarified that he meant the reaction. In his view, companies had already been producing good earnings without consistently receiving credit for them.

The previous day’s strong response to Microsoft’s report provided a comparison for Amazon’s initially weaker trading. Macke thought investors were beginning to put some boundaries around tariff uncertainty. That did not resolve the policy questions or rule out a recession. It made an adverse scenario easier to assess than a threat whose consequences seemed impossible to quantify.

His favorable view of Amazon also rested on its record of allocating capital. He pointed to successful businesses beyond its original retail operation and its willingness to abandon ideas that had not worked. He considered Prime a particularly valuable relationship with customers.

Apple’s cash return met supply-chain questions

Apple’s results shifted the conversation to China from another direction: manufacturing. The panel questioned how quickly a business operating at Apple’s scale could move production and whether expensive short-term measures could provide a lasting answer.

Macke welcomed Apple’s additional share-repurchase authorization. Apple’s May 1 announcement confirmed that its board had authorized a program to repurchase up to $100 billion of common stock. That was an authorization, with purchases still to be carried out under the program. Apple’s earnings announcement

For Macke, returning cash made sense alongside continued investment in the products customers already valued. He preferred that approach to treating every speculative new product category as something Apple had to pursue.

Another unresolved issue was whether customers had accelerated purchases ahead of possible tariff-related price increases. The panel questioned management’s reported assessment that it had not seen that behavior. They did not have subsequent sales data on the broadcast to settle the disagreement.

The next tests were still ahead

The hosts were reacting before Apple’s earnings discussion was complete. Spencer clarified that an outlook had not yet arrived during their show, so the absence of guidance at that moment was not a final statement about what Apple would provide.

Macke still wanted to see retail reports and more evidence about the economy. Companies had experience adapting supply chains after the pandemic, but that did not remove the risk of weaker demand. For the following session, the immediate test was whether investors would continue selling the reports or reconsider their first reaction. The broadcast ended with that outcome still open.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-05-01 episode.

What concerned Macke about Amazon’s third-party sellers?

He saw slower seller growth as a possible warning about customers’ financial health. Merchants supported Amazon’s fulfillment and other service revenue, so market-share gains would not eliminate the effect of a weaker economy.

Link to this answer

Why did Macke welcome Apple’s repurchase authorization?

He favored returning cash to shareholders while Apple continued investing in its established products. The announcement authorized up to $100 billion of repurchases; it did not mean those purchases had already occurred.

Link to this answer

What did Macke mean when he said the market had turned a corner?

When Strazza asked, Macke clarified that he meant investors’ response to earnings. He believed strong reports were beginning to receive a better reaction, while uncertainty about tariffs and the economy remained.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .