Takeaways

#
  • Macke saw Macy’s sharp rally as a response to low expectations and modest improvement, without treating it as a complete solution to the business’s long-term questions.
  • He argued that a familiar retail short thesis still needed to fit the current valuation, positioning and operating picture.
  • He was long American Eagle ahead of earnings, expecting denim demand and better advertising to support its outlook.
  • He remained skeptical of Lululemon but said he would not initiate a short at the current level, separating his forecast from the entry decision.

Macy's did not need a spectacular quarter to produce a spectacular stock reaction. That was Jeff Macke's starting point on September 3, 2025, as he watched the department-store shares rise about 20% during his live retail review.

He described roughly 1% comparable-sales growth against a backdrop of low expectations. The report had not answered every question about the company's long-term future. It had, however, been enough to change the immediate trade.

Macke carried that distinction into two earnings reports still ahead: American Eagle that evening and Lululemon the following day. He preferred the former, connecting its exposure to denim with a wider fashion shift and a low bar for improvement.

Better than feared could be enough

Macke had asked whether Macy's could catch up after Kohl's rallied. He remained skeptical of Kohl's business and had been concerned by its discussion of slower payments to vendors.

The rebound still mattered. Calling it short covering did not erase the move or make it irrelevant to a trader.

Macy's offered a similar separation between a durable investment case and a near-term opportunity. Macke saw a business that had repeatedly disappointed, finally producing a quarter with positive comparable sales. A modest improvement could surprise investors who expected another bad result.

Gap had also recovered after an initially weak reaction to its report. Taken together, these responses made him question how much further some bearish retail positions could run without fresh deterioration.

An old short thesis could become stale

Signet Jewelers was another example. Macke had once liked it as a short, but he no longer considered that old view sufficient.

He challenged the idea that lab-grown diamonds necessarily undermined the business. A retailer selling accessible engagement rings could still serve customers looking for affordable jewelry, even if the source or price of the stones changed.

His concern was the combination of pessimistic positioning and a valuation that already reflected plenty of doubt. He had not captured every rebound himself. The point was to reassess whether the current business and price still supported a familiar bearish argument.

Denim gave American Eagle a specific opportunity

Macke disclosed that he was long American Eagle going into the evening's report. He expected a weak second quarter, but thought the outlook could be more encouraging.

He saw supportive back-to-school activity, stronger denim demand and advertising that made the brand more visible. He estimated that denim represented roughly 40% of its product mix, making that fashion trend relevant to the company's results.

He was also conscious of the low expectations after earlier guidance problems. The thesis did not require every part of the retailer to be thriving. It required enough improvement to change what investors expected next.

His preference was explicitly comparative: he liked American Eagle more than Lululemon ahead of their respective announcements. Both results were still unknown when he recorded the episode.

Lululemon had competition on two fronts

Macke thought Lululemon faced a shift away from its core athleisure category and competition from private brands such as Vuori and Alo.

He pointed to Vuori adding denim as an example of adapting to the change. In his view, Lululemon was responding less effectively while still trading at a valuation he did not find compelling.

His own comparison of Lululemon with a basket of denim-related stocks reinforced that concern. He saw the relative trend worsening.

He was nevertheless explicit that he would not initiate a short at the current level. He thought the chart could eventually reach $150, but a bearish forecast and a sensible new entry were separate decisions.

Holiday forecasts still needed to meet actual behavior

Macke also challenged a pessimistic holiday-spending survey. He doubted that consumers' stated intentions months ahead would map cleanly onto their eventual purchases.

His alternative was to follow store activity, reported results and the shares of businesses consumers used. He had built his own consumer-stock basket because he thought conventional sector groupings missed part of that activity.

He expected a strong Christmas season overall while acknowledging that individual retailers would still lose ground. The immediate earnings calendar offered a nearer test: whether American Eagle's denim exposure and renewed advertising could produce a more favorable outlook than investors had allowed for.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-09-03 episode.

Why did Macke think Macy’s rallied so sharply?

He saw low expectations meeting a quarter with modest positive comparable sales. The result could support a trade even though he still questioned the retailer’s long-term position.

Link to this answer

What did he prefer about American Eagle ahead of earnings?

He liked its exposure to denim, its advertising and signs of solid back-to-school demand. He expected a weak quarter but thought the outlook could improve enough to change expectations.

Link to this answer

Was Macke recommending a new Lululemon short in this episode?

He said he would not short it at the current level. He was cautious about fashion trends, competition and valuation, and thought $150 was possible, but did not treat that forecast as an attractive immediate entry.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .