Takeaways

#
  • Macke treated Chewy's intraday recovery as consistent with a steady business rather than evidence of a new high-growth phase.
  • Improving but still-negative comparable sales did not satisfy his operating test for Dave & Buster's.
  • Costco's membership model remained attractive to him, but its valuation demanded another reason to commit new money.
  • He saw positive North American comparable sales as a potential Lululemon surprise, while remaining uncertain about RH's increasingly complicated business.

A sharp stock move was not enough to settle Jeff Macke's view of a retailer. In his December 10, 2025 conversation with Spencer Israel, he kept returning to the operating business: whether customers were coming back, whether merchandise was working and how much improvement the valuation already assumed.

Chewy and Dave & Buster's had reported. Costco, Lululemon and RH were still ahead on the earnings calendar discussed in the episode. Macke saw different problems in each, even after several had endured difficult years in the market.

Chewy's recovery did not create a new growth story

Chewy had recovered much of an early post-report decline by the time of the conversation. Macke said the results were neither especially good nor especially bad, and treated the business as a test of consistency.

He regarded it as well run but operating in a difficult category without the growth excitement it once carried. The intraday reversal did not radically change that assessment. In his view, investors who had liked the business before the report had little reason to reach a completely different conclusion because of the initial selloff.

He also said he had previously owned the stock and moved on. His willingness to acknowledge a stable business was separate from enthusiasm about owning it again.

Dave & Buster's needed customers, not just a stronger chart

Dave & Buster's had the more dramatic rally. Macke nevertheless described it as another attempt at a turnaround whose earlier remodeling plans had disappointed.

Comparable-store sales had improved, but remained negative. When Israel asked whether a move above the 200-day moving average would make the stock more interesting, Macke pointed back to traffic. He wanted customer trends to become positive.

For him, a smaller decline was progress without yet being growth. The stock could rally strongly as expectations changed, but the company still had to demonstrate that its venues could attract more business. He was not persuaded to change his view by the share-price move alone.

Costco's business quality came with a demanding price

Macke expected limited surprise from Costco because its monthly sales disclosures had already provided much of the operating picture. He still admired the membership model and the company's ability to market itself.

His hesitation concerned the stock's valuation and the next catalyst. He cited a price of roughly 43 times earnings during the recording and said a new investment required a compelling argument at that level.

The prior membership-fee increase had already supplied one source of growth. He was looking for what might follow, while acknowledging that a strong retailer could spend extended periods consolidating in the market. He did not expect one routine report to transform a difficult trading year.

Lululemon had low expectations and a specific test

Lululemon presented the reverse valuation problem. Macke described it as much cheaper than before, around 14 times earnings in his comparison, but questioned its merchandising and recent communication with investors.

He pointed to an earlier pattern of beating quarterly expectations while lowering the full-year outlook. That combination had undermined confidence. He also doubted that repeated references to a reluctant consumer fully explained the company's weakness when other retailers were producing better results.

The potential positive surprise was specific: North American comparable sales returning to growth. He did not expect that result, but thought it could change the stock's reception if delivered. A lower valuation made a rebound possible; it did not establish that the merchandise or customer trends had improved.

RH's expansion complicated the earnings question

With RH, Macke was less certain about what the report would show. He questioned the move from expensive furniture into real estate, restaurants and other experiences, emphasizing how demanding those businesses could be to run.

He also distinguished management's colorful commentary about the consumer and housing market from a dependable forecast of the company's results. He was interested in the call, but did not offer a confident earnings prediction.

Of the two more beaten-down names, he regarded Lululemon as having the more coherent business model and a clearer route to a positive surprise. He still entered the reports with restrained expectations for both. The operating evidence, especially customer growth and a credible path forward, remained the test.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-12-10 episode.

Why was Macke unconvinced by the Dave & Buster's rally?

He wanted positive customer traffic and business growth. A smaller decline in comparable sales and a stronger stock chart did not yet meet that standard.

Link to this answer

What could have changed Lululemon's earnings reception?

Macke said positive North American comparable sales could be a meaningful surprise. He considered it possible rather than expected.

Link to this answer

What concerned Macke about Costco's valuation?

He wanted a compelling new catalyst at the valuation discussed in the episode. Monthly sales disclosures had already supplied much of the operating picture, so he expected limited surprise from the report itself.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .