Takeaways
#- Costco's monthly sales disclosures left Macke looking to management commentary and membership retention for information beyond the familiar sales story.
- Stitch Fix's lower expectations made stabilization and a credible return to growth more important than comparisons with its pandemic-era stock peak.
- Macke thought a stabilized, profitable Stitch Fix could become attractive to private equity.
- His longer-term interest in Stitch Fix did not remove the possibility of a sharp earnings-related decline or a volatile recovery.
Costco and Stitch Fix faced very different earnings tests in Jeff Macke's September 24, 2025 conversation with Spencer Israel. Costco had to justify investors' high expectations for an exceptional business. Stitch Fix needed to show that a much smaller company could stop shrinking and establish a credible path forward.
Macke liked aspects of both stories, but he did not expect the same evidence from them. Costco was due to report the following evening; Stitch Fix was scheduled for that night. The discussion took place before either report.
Costco's strength was already widely understood
Macke remained a Costco shareholder and spoke highly of its business. His reservation concerned the stock's valuation and the amount of good news investors already knew.
Costco's monthly sales disclosures reduced the room for a major surprise. Investors did not need the quarterly release to discover whether sales had been healthy throughout the period. That made management's commentary particularly important to him.
He wanted to hear how inflation and tariffs were affecting the company and its shoppers. Costco's customer base also offered a way to assess the health of higher-income consumers. Macke was not predicting a sudden deterioration, but unexpected weakness among those shoppers would have challenged the comfortable view of the business.
Membership retention was another test. After the membership-price increase, he wanted to see whether customers continued to renew. He had not identified an emerging retention problem in the discussion; he was describing what he would inspect in the report.
Those questions distinguished owning a strong business from assuming its next earnings announcement would automatically produce a strong stock reaction. Macke's continued ownership did not prevent him from questioning how much upside a richly valued, closely followed company could deliver on familiar information.
Stitch Fix needed to make a smaller business work
Stitch Fix presented almost the reverse problem. Its share price had fallen far from the pandemic-era peak, and expectations had become much more modest. Macke was interested in whether the company could retain a loyal core of customers after reducing the business to a more sustainable size.
He placed it within a broader group of subscription businesses that had expanded around assumptions that pandemic demand would persist. When those assumptions failed, the companies had to adjust their operations to a different market. The old peak was evidence of how much expectations had changed, rather than a destination he expected the stock to revisit.
Macke saw two possible paths from that point. A company could continue shrinking while extracting cash from its remaining customer base. Alternatively, it could stabilize and eventually return to growth. The second path offered the more attractive stock story, but it still needed operating evidence.
He thought Stitch Fix had made progress in reducing its problems. His next question was whether it could stop contracting. A low share price by itself could not answer that question.
A credible plan still needed execution
Macke argued that management needed to explain a believable plan and then deliver against it. He believed investors remained skeptical of the growth story, which created an opportunity if the company eventually proved them wrong.
He also discussed a possible private-equity acquisition as one way value might be realized if the business became sufficiently attractive.
Nor did he expect a single earnings night necessarily to resolve the entire thesis. Stabilizing revenue and establishing a dependable business could take longer than one quarterly report. His interest in the longer-term possibility coexisted with substantial uncertainty about the immediate stock reaction.
When Israel raised the possibility of a sharp decline after earnings, Macke acknowledged that it could happen. He recalled earlier volatility to emphasize how difficult the path could be even when an investor remained interested in the company.
Consumer strength did not make every retail stock equivalent
The comparison sat within Macke's broader view that actual consumer spending looked healthier than the mood suggested by surveys and commentary. His consumer-stock basket had benefited from different names at different times, rather than every holding advancing together.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-09-24 episode.
What did Macke want to learn from Costco's earnings report?
He focused on inflation and tariff commentary, the health of higher-income shoppers and membership retention after the price increase. Monthly sales disclosures already gave investors substantial information about the sales trend.
What was the main operating test for Stitch Fix?
Macke wanted to see whether the company could stop shrinking, retain its core customers and eventually produce credible growth after adjusting to lower demand than pandemic-era expectations implied.
Why did Macke think Stitch Fix could attract a buyer?
He thought a shift from shrinking revenue toward slow growth could let the company generate more profit from its existing business. That could make it attractive to private equity, though he doubted one earnings report would resolve the thesis.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .