Takeaways

#
  • Macke wanted Walmart to explain consumer purchasing and supply-chain decisions alongside its earnings outlook.
  • Earlier buying by shoppers and earlier inventory orders by retailers could affect later demand differently.
  • Healthy grocery sales could coexist with weak discretionary spending, making Walmart’s category detail relevant to Target.
  • American Eagle’s warning and On’s strong growth supported his view that shoppers were choosing carefully among retailers.

Jeff Macke wanted more than an earnings number from Walmart (WMT). Speaking with Spencer Israel on May 14, 2025, ahead of the company’s scheduled report the following morning, he was looking for a current account of what shoppers were buying and how the retailer was managing its supply chain.

Walmart’s mix of groceries and discretionary merchandise made that account useful beyond its own stock. Macke thought its comments could help investors interpret the results still to come from Target (TGT) and other retailers. A strong Walmart report would not necessarily mean the same thing for every competitor.

Guidance was one test of management’s visibility

Macke expected Walmart to hold its outlook. He wanted to hear whether management had enough visibility to do so while trade policy and purchasing decisions were changing. He also thought the stock’s valuation left little room for disappointment.

The more interesting questions concerned the business behind that forecast. Who would absorb tariff-related costs? How would Walmart try to preserve low prices? Where was it investing, and could its scale help it gain customers while competitors struggled?

He was particularly interested in purchases moving forward in time. Consumers might buy goods earlier because they expected prices to rise. Retailers could also bring inventory forward while import costs were temporarily lower.

Those were two different decisions with consequences for later demand and stock levels. Macke wanted Walmart to explain how it was adjusting orders and keeping merchandise available, rather than assume that a burst of buying meant a lasting increase in consumption.

Groceries could conceal weakness elsewhere

Walmart could report healthy overall results while delivering an uncomfortable message about discretionary spending. Macke thought that distinction mattered especially for Target, whose merchandise mix left it more exposed to purchases shoppers could postpone.

He was skeptical about Target’s prospects and pointed to its weak stock performance relative to Walmart. He wanted to listen closely for what Walmart said about apparel and other discretionary categories before interpreting Target’s own report.

The comparison also involved execution. In Macke’s view, Walmart had been improving its offering and taking share. A competitor could face pressure from the economy and still have company-specific problems making the situation worse.

American Eagle and On showed different consumers’ choices

American Eagle Outfitters (AEO) had already delivered a warning. Its May 13 preliminary release described excess inventory, a roughly $75 million merchandise write-down and the withdrawal of full-year guidance.

Macke contrasted that weakness with Gap (GAP), whose stock was holding up much better in the discussion. He took the divergence as evidence that shoppers were becoming more selective about where they spent. He was also watching whether the recovering market would continue supporting weaker companies once more reports arrived.

On Holding (ONON) offered a stronger operating example. Its May 13 results showed Americas sales up 32.7% in reported Swiss-franc terms, alongside growth across its channels and regions.

Macke saw the brand expanding beyond its initial audience. He thought customers were still willing to spend on products they wanted, even as other retailers struggled to clear merchandise. That raised expectations for the premium brands yet to report, including Ralph Lauren (RL).

He wanted investors to compare each release with the others. American Eagle’s warning made Gap worth watching; On’s strength raised the bar for another apparel report. Walmart’s next-morning update would add a much broader view of groceries, discretionary purchases and the choices being made along the supply chain.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2025-05-14 episode.

Why was Walmart’s report useful for assessing other retailers?

Macke emphasized its scale and combination of groceries and discretionary products. Its comments could provide context for competitors with different merchandise mixes, including Target.

Link to this answer

What did he want to know about purchases moving forward?

He wanted to distinguish consumers stocking up ahead of possible price increases from retailers ordering inventory while import costs were temporarily lower. Both could change the timing of spending and deliveries.

Link to this answer

Why did he compare American Eagle with On?

American Eagle had warned about weak execution, excess inventory and its outlook, while On reported strong growth. Macke saw evidence of selective spending rather than a single consumer trend affecting every retailer equally.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .