Takeaways
#- Shull described anticipated regret as a source of pressure for traders with winning positions as well as those who missed a rally.
- Scaling into or out of a position can reduce the emotional burden placed on one entry or exit decision.
- She encouraged traders to recognize recurring feelings and control their actions without expecting all discomfort to disappear.
- Her account of useful intuition depended on learned recognition within a trading method the person understood.
Two traders can sell at the same price and feel equally disappointed. One sells at $100 before the stock reaches $150. The other watches it reach $150, then sells after it returns to $100. Each judges the decision against the money that might have been made.
Sean McLaughlin offered that example during an Off the Charts conversation with Denise Shull and Steve Strazza, recorded November 13, 2024. Shull saw a common problem beneath both reactions: the fear of future regret, including the prospect of feeling foolish or becoming angry with oneself.
Winning can make the next decision harder
The hosts described traders who had benefited from the post-election rally but were becoming anxious about their gains. Selling could mean missing a further advance. Holding could mean giving the profit back. Traders who had missed the rally faced their own pressure to catch up.
Shull argued that people already making money could experience a powerful form of FOMO. A winner did not exempt them from second-guessing. Once a position pulled back, regret about failing to sell higher could make the next exit even harder.
Her response was to examine the expected regret more closely. Was the trader worried about the position itself, or about what a disappointing result would seem to say about their ability? Identifying that concern could help distinguish a market judgment from an effort to avoid feeling bad.
She encouraged traders to develop a personal dictionary of their recurring emotional patterns. Someone who repeatedly exited too early, for example, could investigate the fear of surrendering gains and the self-criticism attached to it. The purpose was to recognize the pattern while deciding what to do.
Scaling reduces the pressure on a single decision
Shull described scaling into and out of positions as a practical response to the impossibility of finding a perfect price every time. Taking part of a profitable position off could preserve some exposure while realizing some gains. It did not require a trader to decide that the entire move was over.
Strazza said dividing an entry into several purchases reduced the pressure he felt around any one purchase. McLaughlin’s two-trader example made the emotional tradeoff visible: both a premature exit and a late one could create regret, even with the same sale price.
The approach did not promise to capture the top or remove every uncomfortable feeling. Shull treated discomfort as something a trader could learn to identify and tolerate while controlling the action taken in response.
Intuition needs experience behind it
That distinction also shaped Shull’s view of intuition. She described useful intuition as a relatively calm recognition of something familiar, comparable to recognizing a person one had not seen in years. A strong urge driven by fear of looking foolish was a different kind of experience.
Recognition required a foundation. A trader needed a method that made sense to them, including the time frame, pattern and type of movement they were trying to trade. Shull suggested that they should be able to explain that approach away from the screen, on a Saturday afternoon.
She cautioned against repeatedly abandoning one method for another before developing that understanding. In her experience, traders could use very different approaches successfully, but they still needed enough practice to recognize what their own approach was telling them. A lucky winning trade did not provide that experience by itself.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-11-22 episode.
Why can a winning trade create FOMO?
Selling may leave the trader fearing a further advance, while holding may create anxiety about surrendering gains. Shull said both situations can involve anticipated regret and self-criticism.
How did Shull suggest handling that pressure?
She discussed identifying the feeling behind the decision and using partial entries or exits to avoid placing all the pressure on one price. She did not suggest that traders could eliminate regret or consistently capture exact tops and bottoms.
How did she distinguish intuition from impulse?
Shull described useful intuition as calm recognition built through experience. She contrasted it with feelings focused on the trader’s fear of looking foolish, which needed to be examined before acting.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .