Takeaways
#- Nauss used average true range to make the momentum input more comparable across different markets.
- He described the initial backtest as preliminary and said he was not yet ready to trade it.
- He began with a simple indicator-led rule before considering additional volume or trend filters.
- Weak momentum results alongside stronger mean reversion helped him identify a choppy trading environment.
Michael Nauss arrived at the December 16, 2025 Morning Show with an indicator he had only recently started testing. It combined MACD with average true range, giving him a way to compare momentum readings across markets with different price and volatility characteristics.
His enthusiasm came with a clear limit: the initial backtest was rough, and he was not ready to trade the strategy. The useful part of the conversation was how he intended to move from an interesting indicator toward a system he could evaluate more thoroughly.
Steve Strazza recognized the appeal of a familiar momentum tool expressed in a more comparable form. Spencer Israel wanted to know what Nauss could learn from the names appearing in his scans and from the strategies that were working best.
Comparable inputs came before a trading rule
Nauss described the ordinary MACD's scale as a problem for the kind of research he wanted to conduct. A reading on one security could mean something very different from the same number on another, and changes in price over time complicated comparisons further.
A percentage-based oscillator addressed part of that issue, but Nauss was interested in adjusting for volatility. Dividing the momentum measure by average true range gave him an input he could use more consistently across his tests.
He also wanted to examine both trend and overbought or oversold conditions with the same tool. In the version he presented, a low reading followed by an upward cross could identify a potential mean-reversion entry within an uptrend.
Bitcoin was one of the examples he brought. The tentative signal was interesting to him precisely because it differed from the broadly defensive interpretation of crypto price action. It was still an illustration of his research, not a finished trading system.
The first test deliberately left other filters out
Nauss's initial rule was simple: look for an uptrend, wait for the adjusted indicator to become oversold and cross higher, then hold until it crossed back down.
When Strazza asked whether the scan required a new high, Nauss said it did not. At that stage, he wanted the test to revolve around the indicator so he could examine what it contributed.
Additional conditions could come later. He discussed possible filters involving volume, trend strength, proximity to highs and whether a stock was above its 200-day moving average. But layering those choices on too early could obscure what generated the result.
He wanted an interesting base case first, then a more selective system. Simply adding conditions until the equity curve looked attractive would not answer the question he was trying to study.
Philip Morris illustrated the scan rather than proving the strategy
Philip Morris was one of the stocks produced by the preliminary test. Nauss described the condition as an oversold reading within the previous twenty days followed by a turn higher.
The chart had shown different results from earlier signals: one preceded a substantial advance, while another produced much less. Strazza was separately interested in the stock and wanted it above an anchored VWAP before adding more.
Hershey also appeared in the discussion, reinforcing a broader observation about familiar, less speculative companies attracting attention. The scan gave the panel specific charts to examine while Nauss continued developing the method behind it.
Strategy performance was another way to read the market
Nauss looked beyond the individual stocks his systems selected. He also compared the results of different approaches.
At the time, his momentum strategy was struggling, while mean reversion and pullback trading were performing better. He interpreted that combination as evidence of a choppy market rather than a clean environment for buying every new high.
The composition of a scan could provide another clue. A concentration of income funds, including Blackstone Secured Lending Fund, suggested that his momentum criteria were finding fewer exciting candidates. A cluster of healthcare or energy stocks would instead direct his attention toward that sector.
Regional banks had become a more frequent part of his own trading. He argued that traders needed to follow where opportunities were appearing, even when those companies were less exciting than the technology names they preferred to watch.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-12-16 episode.
Why did Nauss adjust MACD for volatility?
He wanted momentum readings that could be compared more consistently across securities and through time. Average true range supplied the volatility adjustment for the version he was researching.
Why did the initial test exclude a new-high requirement?
He wanted to isolate what the indicator contributed before adding other conditions. Trend, volume and proximity-to-high filters were possibilities for later development.
What did his strategy results say about the market?
His momentum strategy was struggling while mean reversion and pullback trading were working better. He read that difference as evidence of a choppy environment requiring a different approach from chasing new highs.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .