Takeaways
#- Grant’s risk indicator had weakened but remained in its risk-on range; he wanted price confirmation before changing exposure.
- Weak new-high participation was not accompanied by a sharp expansion in new lows.
- The December breadth thrust remained part of his assessment even as more recent readings deteriorated.
- Dunuwila saw $500 as a plausible pause for QQQ, while McLaughlin considered an overshoot toward $505; QQQ crossed $500 during the show.
The market’s largest stocks were making new highs, but many smaller companies were not participating. On the July 10, 2024 Morning Show, the All Star Charts analyst team worked through that imbalance without agreeing that it marked an imminent top.
Steve Strazza hosted with JC Parets and Spencer Israel away. Grant Hawkridge brought the breadth data, Patrick Dunuwila examined the charts approaching price objectives, and Sean McLaughlin later challenged the idea that a conspicuous target necessarily had to stop a rally.
Deterioration had not become a sell signal
Grant’s long-term risk indicator combined 20 pairs and remained in its risk-on range, although it had weakened. He cared about the divergence, but would place more weight on an actual move into the risk-off range. A divergence could persist for a long time while prices continued rising.
The same distinction applied to new highs. Participation looked weak across large, mid-sized and small companies, with the greatest weakness among the smaller stocks. Yet new lows were not expanding sharply either. Grant did not see enough evidence to treat the lack of new highs as an instruction to change his portfolio.
He described breadth as a way to understand the trading environment. Choosing a position still required him to examine its price trend, momentum and relative strength. A weak aggregate reading did not prevent an individual stock from offering a constructive chart.
An earlier bullish signal still counted
Grant also discussed a 20-day-high breadth thrust that he continued to include in his assessment. His description used a threshold of more than 55% of S&P 500 stocks reaching 20-day highs. The signal had triggered in December, and his framework evaluated its favorable environment over the following year.
That earlier event could be easy to forget while investors concentrated on the latest deterioration. He used it alongside several other models rather than discarding it because the daily commentary had become more anxious.
Dunuwila asked about the opposite kind of warning: a sudden expansion in new lows. Grant explained the “fall day” concept associated with Mike Hurley’s work. That warning had not triggered in the conditions they were discussing. Even when it did, they would still look for price confirmation before concluding that the market had changed direction.
Price targets produced different outcomes
Dunuwila was more cautious about several important charts reaching upside objectives. Semiconductor leadership remained intact, but its steep advance and relative-strength target made a pause plausible.
The homebuilders provided one example of how that could look. The iShares U.S. Home Construction ETF (ITB) had spent months pausing around an extension level. Some technology charts, by contrast, had continued through their initial objectives. Dunuwila acknowledged that the broad indexes could do the same.
Strazza also considered a rotation: the largest stocks might consolidate while participation improved elsewhere. A sideways index would not necessarily mean that every stock underneath it was standing still. Financials were already showing more strength than several other cyclical groups.
QQQ put the disagreement on screen
The Invesco QQQ Trust (QQQ) was testing $500, a round number that also aligned with Dunuwila’s extension target. After several consecutive advances, he regarded it as a logical place for a pause or a bout of volatility.
McLaughlin took the other side. He thought the obviousness of the level could help produce an overshoot, and discussed $505 as a possibility if momentum continued. He described how stocks approaching large round numbers sometimes moved beyond them before rolling over.
Dunuwila accepted that possibility and said he was long QQQ. Later, during Mary Thwaites’s segment, the presenters interrupted the discussion as the fund moved above $500. That crossing supplied a live test of their competing expectations; the episode did not settle how the broader consolidation would eventually develop.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2024-07-10 episode.
Why did weak breadth not automatically change Grant’s portfolio?
His risk indicator remained in its risk-on range, and new lows were not expanding sharply. He wanted the individual price charts and other evidence to confirm a change.
What did the 20-day breadth thrust measure?
Grant described a signal triggered when more than 55% of S&P 500 stocks reached 20-day highs. His framework continued to consider the December signal over the following year.
Why did McLaughlin think QQQ could pass $500?
He thought the widely watched round number could attract momentum and be exceeded before a reversal. He discussed $505 as a possible overshoot, while Dunuwila regarded $500 as a logical place for a pause.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .