Takeaways
#- Hirsch treated the Santa Claus rally as a market-health indicator rather than an automatic year-end entry.
- The first five trading days and the full January barometer were distinct parts of his seasonal framework.
- His small-cap thesis needed a sustained breakout, while the separate free-lunch screen targeted short bounces in depressed stocks.
- Transports, copper miners, software and insurance supplied specific examples of the rotation the panel was following.
Jeff Hirsch wanted to clear up a familiar December misunderstanding. A year-end rally was something traders might try to anticipate. The Santa Claus rally, as he used it, was an indicator that helped assess the market environment.
On the December 15, 2025 Morning Show, Hirsch told Spencer Israel and Steve Strazza that a failure to advance during that seasonal window would be a reason to investigate other warning signs. It would not, by itself, settle the outlook for the coming year.
That distinction shaped the rest of the discussion: seasonal patterns could organize a watchlist and supply useful context, but their meaning depended on what prices actually did.
Three January indicators answered related questions
Hirsch placed the Santa Claus rally within his January indicator trifecta, alongside the first five trading days of January and the full-month January barometer.
He emphasized the word trading. The first five trading days were not necessarily the same thing as the first calendar week. The full-month barometer was a separate observation, completed only after the entire month had unfolded.
He described favorable historical results when all three indicators were positive, while acknowledging that the record included failures. Strazza liked that qualification: an undefeated record could make him more suspicious, not less.
For Hirsch, a weak seasonal signal prompted a closer look at the technical evidence. The point was to learn about the environment before treating a calendar pattern as a forecast.
Small-cap season had moved earlier
Hirsch was already constructive on small caps and held Russell exposure along with individual names. He explained that the pattern commonly called the January effect had shifted, with much of the relative strength appearing during the last two weeks of December and sometimes beginning earlier in the autumn.
He also noted that small caps could join a bull market later in its development. Their participation was welcome, but did not mean the cycle was newly beginning.
Strazza focused on the repeated frustration in the Russell 2000. The index had spent years near the same broad levels, and he wanted its latest breakout to hold. A seasonal tendency would be more useful if the price structure finally confirmed it.
Hirsch agreed that sustained participation mattered. He wanted the rotation into small caps to produce an actual advance rather than another brief attempt that faded.
The free-lunch screen sought a short bounce
Hirsch described a separate year-end approach known as the Almanac's free-lunch trade. It looked for heavily declined common stocks making new 52-week lows around mid-December, after tax-loss selling had put pressure on them.
The screen was not limited to small caps, although smaller companies often appeared. Hirsch wanted a full year of trading history, enough liquidity and a usable share price. He excluded closed-end funds and situations distorted by unusual splits or special dividends.
He was looking for a short-lived bounce, not a stock to become attached to. When Strazza described the idea as mean reversion, Hirsch narrowed the intention: the objective was a near-term pop from a depressed starting point.
Transports and copper supplied specific expressions of the outlook
Hirsch favored combining seasonal tendencies with technical confirmation. He discussed his exposure to transports through IYT and copper miners through COPX.
Strazza saw Freeport-McMoRan's long sideways period as a digestion of its earlier advance. Southern Copper also looked stronger to him. Hirsch said both had been part of his copper seasonal work, though he currently preferred the basket because it reduced the need to monitor each company separately.
When asked to choose an area for the turn of the year, Hirsch returned to small caps. Industrials and copper miners also interested him. He was less convinced about energy and was looking for a better entry there.
Gatlin preferred working software charts to a predicted crypto catch-up
Sam Gatlin joined later and pointed to improving price action in Salesforce and Adobe. He thought their strength could be constructive for crypto, given the relationship he followed between software and Bitcoin.
Strazza's response was to stay with the evidence already visible. The improvement was helping software now; a crypto catch-up remained a possibility. Gatlin agreed that trading the names already working was simpler than waiting for a related market to respond.
Gatlin also highlighted insurance, including KIE's consolidation and the charts of Chubb and Progressive. That extended the day's rotation discussion into another group outside the most crowded technology themes.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-12-15 episode.
How did Hirsch distinguish the Santa Claus rally from a year-end trade?
He used the Santa Claus window to gather information about market health. A failure to advance would prompt him to examine other technical warning signs, rather than automatically predict a bear market.
What is the difference between the first five days and the January barometer?
The first-five-days indicator covers the first five trading sessions, which need not equal a calendar week. The January barometer uses the performance of the entire month.
What did the free-lunch stock screen seek?
Hirsch looked for heavily declined common stocks near new 52-week lows around mid-December, with sufficient trading history and liquidity. He wanted a short bounce following tax-loss pressure rather than a long-term commitment.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .