Takeaways
#- Netflix reported 9.33 million net paid additions, $9.37 billion in revenue and $5.28 in diluted earnings per share for the first quarter of 2024.
- The company argued that different price tiers, advertising and extra-member revenue made each new membership worth a different amount.
- Strazza valued the quarterly count as a check on performance even as Israel saw a case for judging a mature streaming business on profit.
Netflix had just added 9.33 million paid memberships in a quarter, more than five times the number it added a year earlier. It also told shareholders that, starting with the first quarter of 2025, it would stop publishing its quarterly membership count and average revenue per membership. On the April 19, 2024 Morning Show, Spencer Israel and Steve Strazza saw two ways to read that announcement.
Israel started with the quarter Netflix had delivered. Revenue reached $9.37 billion and diluted earnings came in at $5.28 per share, ahead of the company’s own $4.49 forecast. Netflix expected to add fewer memberships in the second quarter than in the first, a slowdown it attributed to normal seasonality. A slower pace of additions still meant the membership base could grow.
What one more membership was worth
When Netflix depended on subscriptions at a smaller number of price points, another paying household told investors quite a bit about the business. By 2024, two new households could choose different tiers at different prices. One might see ads and generate advertising revenue as well. Netflix could also charge for an extra member on an existing account.
That was the case for looking beyond the headline count. As Israel put it, Netflix was trying to make more money from the audience it had built. In its April 18 shareholder letter, the company identified revenue growth and operating margin as its primary financial measures. Its operating margin had reached 28.1%, up from 21% a year earlier.
What investors would lose
Strazza understood why management wanted to discuss profits. His objection was that investors would lose a number they had used to judge management’s progress through good quarters and bad. Israel brought up the two quarters of membership contraction a couple of years earlier. Investors had been able to see that reversal and then watch the recovery as Netflix tightened its password-sharing rules and released new programming.
Netflix said it would still announce major subscriber milestones. Those announcements could tell investors when Netflix crossed a round number. They wouldn’t tell them how quickly the paid membership base grew or shrank from one quarter to the next. Strazza thought Netflix was ahead of its streaming rivals; he wanted a way to keep testing that lead.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-04-19 episode.
When did Netflix say quarterly membership reporting would end?
It announced in April 2024 that quarterly membership counts and average revenue per membership would no longer appear starting with its first-quarter 2025 earnings.
Did Netflix predict a loss of subscribers in the next quarter?
No. It expected fewer net additions than in the first quarter, citing seasonality. Net additions measure growth after subtracting departures.
What would investors still get from Netflix?
Netflix said it would keep reporting revenue by region and announce major subscriber milestones. It emphasized revenue and operating margin as its main financial measures.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .