Takeaways

#
  • Thrasher’s initial signal measured how quickly an index declined 5% from a 52-week high. On Friday’s figures, the S&P 500 had not yet reached it.
  • The VIX had risen gradually, without the inversion in its futures curve that might accompany a more urgent scramble for protection.
  • A deeply negative breadth reading left room for a short-term bounce. Thrasher also wanted to see the S&P hold 4,300 and major growth stocks recover key prices.

At the previous Friday’s close, the S&P 500 was down about 4.6% in 14 trading days, by Andrew Thrasher’s count. People who knew his research had started sending him messages. One more down day could put the decline inside the window he studied: 5% off a 52-week high within 15 trading days.

On the August 21, 2023 Morning Show, Thrasher explained what he was looking for. In his paper, *The 5% Canary*, he had compared how quickly the S&P 500 and the Dow lost their first 5% with what happened afterward. Several of the largest declines started with a swift fall. A market that took longer to lose the same amount often lacked that early selling momentum. He gave little weight to the precise difference between the fourteenth and sixteenth day. He wanted to know how urgently investors were selling.

A brisk selloff without a rush for protection

The volatility market hadn’t shown him much panic. The VIX had climbed from about 13 to an intraday reading near 18, but the climb had been gradual. The VIX futures curve had flattened in places without inverting. Thrasher saw little evidence that investors were rushing to protect themselves against a sustained decline.

Underneath the index, he saw a reason it might bounce. The adjusted McClellan Oscillator, which tracks the balance of advancing and declining stocks, had fallen below −100 the previous Thursday. Thrasher had seen rebounds from those lopsided readings even during the 2022 bear market. A bounce alone wouldn’t distinguish a temporary recovery from a lasting one.

For that, he was watching 4,300 on the S&P 500 and the former highs in technology, consumer discretionary and growth stocks. He thought holding above 4,300 would be constructive. The largest companies didn’t have to lead every advance, but a durable index rally would be difficult if Apple, Microsoft and Nvidia kept falling.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-08-21 episode.

Why did Thrasher distinguish a fast 5% decline from a slow one?

In his research, several large drawdowns developed after an initial 5% loss in 15 trading days or less. A slower decline could leave less downside momentum. The fast decline was a warning to investigate, not a prediction of a crash.

Link to this answer

What did a McClellan Oscillator reading below −100 tell him?

In that episode, it told him selling had become lopsided enough for a bounce. Similar bounces had occurred during a bear market, so he did not use the reading to call a final low.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .