Takeaways

#
  • Shapiro read crowded silver longs as a source of potential selling; price still had to turn before he would trade against them.
  • Speculators had covered their Dow shorts. Shapiro saw no remaining positioning edge for his strategy, even if the rally continued.
  • He followed Bitcoin futures positioning but said he did not trade those contracts because their history was too short for his testing.

The silver chart Jason Shapiro brought to the December 11, 2023 Morning Show showed two things happening in sequence. Large speculators had built up long positions near the highs. Then silver fell. A crowd of buyers had become a crowd of people holding losing positions, some of whom might have to sell.

Shapiro could see the buying in the Commitments of Traders data. He couldn't see a top in those numbers alone. Traders had also crowded into silver near its May and July highs, but a market could stay crowded much longer than someone betting against it could afford to wait. He wanted price to start moving the other way before taking a trade.

Why he had no trade in the Dow

The Dow futures chart showed the other end of that process. Speculators had been heavily short near the October lows. As the Dow rose, they bought back contracts. By the broadcast, Shapiro said, the short position that had made the trade interesting was gone. He had no Dow position.

That wasn't a call for the rally to end. The same traders could go on to build long positions and push the market higher. Shapiro described his job as catching the turn; his clients could hire trend followers for the part that came after it. He generally looked to exit when positioning moved back toward neutral, even if that left money on the table.

What Bitcoin could and couldn't tell him

In Bitcoin futures he saw traders selling into a rising price. Earlier advances had stalled when speculators were long. More recent advances had held as they turned short. If prices kept rising, those short sellers represented potential buyers. But Shapiro said the futures history was still too short for him to test his approach to his satisfaction. He followed the data; he did not trade Bitcoin futures.

His clearest example of putting the numbers to work was less exotic. He had recently been long the Swiss franc. When the positioning report went neutral on Friday, he said, he got out on Sunday night. Nothing had to be wrong with the currency for his reason to own it to expire.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-12-11 episode.

When did Jason Shapiro generally exit a positioning trade?

When the extreme that justified the entry returned toward neutral. He said this could leave further gains for trend followers.

Link to this answer

Was Shapiro short the Dow after speculators bought back their shorts?

No. He said he had no Dow position. Losing the case for a long did not give him a case for a short.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .