Takeaways
#- Strazza viewed the semiconductor correction as an opportunity for former leaders to rejoin the advance.
- Gatlin gave more weight to a bearish monthly momentum crossover and preferred other opportunities.
- Perz watched a weekly volatility squeeze in SMH while acknowledging that a compressed range could break either way.
- Strazza distinguished semiconductor positions already bought from XLK and SMH trades still being discussed.
Broadcom’s jump after earnings gave Steve Strazza a reason to revisit a group he had approached more cautiously during the summer. On Stock Market TV’s December 13, 2024 Morning Show, he argued that semiconductors were ready to participate again after months of weak relative performance.
Sam Gatlin reached a different conclusion from a slower momentum measure. The two analysts disagreed over how much weight to give that warning while other growth stocks were advancing.
Strazza looked beyond Broadcom’s earnings reaction
Strazza began with XSD, the SPDR S&P Semiconductor ETF. Its modified equal-weight approach offered a broader view of the industry than a chart dominated by the largest chip companies. He saw the fund challenging a major breakout area again after a failed summer attempt and an August decline.
Broadcom’s positive earnings reaction mattered to him because of the company’s prominence in the group. But his larger case rested on the industry chart and its performance relative to the market. He viewed the difficult summer and autumn as a substantial correction within a longer-term advance.
His earlier caution had come from sharp episodes of semiconductor underperformance as other areas gained strength. By December, he interpreted that weakness as a washout rather than the start of a lasting reversal. He expected the group to resume its role among the bull market’s leaders.
Spencer Israel pointed out that this still left a choice between individual leaders and laggards. Strazza agreed that Broadcom represented leadership. He also saw potential in weaker names, but described AMD as a higher-risk opportunity.
Gatlin questioned the monthly momentum signal
Later in the show, Gatlin explained why he was less enthusiastic. He was watching a bearish crossover in the monthly percentage price oscillator for semiconductors. The group had already enjoyed a substantial advance, and he preferred opportunities elsewhere.
Strazza acknowledged the warning. He disagreed about its importance relative to the other charts he was watching. Large growth stocks had strengthened, software was performing well and semiconductor price patterns still had the possibility of resolving higher.
For Strazza, the monthly oscillator was a slow-moving secondary indicator. He placed more weight on those relationships across the market and on the possibility that apparent semiconductor tops would fail. Gatlin’s concern came from the longer-term momentum deterioration itself.
The difference was also visible in their positioning. Strazza said he had bought a collection of semiconductor positions the previous day, using both shares and calls. Gatlin had challenged that decision when reviewing the trades.
Perz watched the range tighten
Jason Perz brought another chart into the discussion: a weekly volatility squeeze in SMH, the VanEck Semiconductor ETF. He saw a compressed range that could precede a substantial move.
The squeeze alone did not establish the direction. Perz initially described it as a setup that could resolve either way, although he favored continuation with the prevailing upward trend. Strazza also pointed to a tight range in onsemi as another example within the group.
Perz connected a possible semiconductor breakout with renewed strength in the largest technology stocks. If both developed, he expected them to support the broader market. His enthusiasm depended on those charts beginning to move, rather than on compression by itself.
The proposed ETF trades were still ahead
Near the end of the broadcast, Alfonso DePablos highlighted renewed strength across large technology companies and the potential for semiconductors to rejoin that leadership. He also favored XSD as a way to judge participation across the industry.
Strazza said an XLK trade had been considered the previous afternoon but had not been placed. He was still interested in that technology-sector exposure and said SMH could be added alongside it, discussing March options as a possible horizon. Those planned ETF positions were separate from the semiconductor shares and calls he had already reported buying.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-12-13 episode.
Why did Strazza favor XSD’s chart?
Its modified equal-weight approach gave him a broader industry view. He saw another attempt to clear a major breakout area after the summer reversal and August decline.
What was Gatlin’s objection?
He was concerned about a bearish crossover in the semiconductor group’s monthly percentage price oscillator and preferred opportunities outside the group.
Had the proposed XLK and SMH trades been placed?
Strazza said the XLK trade discussed the previous afternoon had not been placed. He was considering it alongside SMH, separately from semiconductor shares and calls he had already bought.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .