Takeaways

#
  • Reitmeister’s December 2024 outlook favored small and midcaps over expensive mega caps for 2025.
  • He viewed a quieter S&P 500 as compatible with opportunities elsewhere in equities.
  • He evaluated P/E alongside growth, peer comparisons and other business measures.
  • Both Reitmeister and Parets rejected high short interest as a sufficient reason to buy.

Steve Reitmeister expected a change in market leadership in 2025. In his December 9, 2024 appearance on Stock Market TV’s Morning Show, he anticipated profit-taking in the largest stocks early in the new year and preferred small and midcaps with healthier valuations and growing businesses.

He remained in the risk-on camp. His concern was that the stocks dominating the indexes had already attracted substantial buying, leaving better opportunities elsewhere.

A quieter index could still contain opportunities

Reitmeister expected the S&P 500 to have a less rewarding third year after its strong recovery from the bear-market low. His forecast put a possible 2025 high around 6,300, with much of the year spent below 6,000. For the Russell 2000, he envisioned a gain of roughly 10% to 15%.

He framed that difference as rotation. Money leaving expensive mega caps could find its way into smaller companies rather than leave equities altogether. When JC Parets asked about technology, Reitmeister included it in his preferred economically sensitive areas, but wanted to avoid paying excessive premiums merely because a company had an AI connection.

He also discussed industrials, materials, consumer discretionary and financials. Energy was a less comfortable fit for him. Falling borrowing costs could help larger consumer purchases, he suggested, while employment would remain important to spending.

Size alone did not qualify a stock. He wanted healthy companies that could demonstrate growth when they reported earnings.

A low P/E needed a reason to matter

The valuation discussion started with a common shortcut: treating a low price-to-earnings ratio as sufficient evidence that a stock was attractive, or a high one as proof that it was uninvestable.

Reitmeister rejected both. A company with stronger expected earnings growth could reasonably command a higher multiple than a slower-growing business. He preferred looking at price relative to growth, then combining that with other measures of value and business quality.

At the group level, he found valuations more useful for comparing opportunities. During the broadcast, he cited a forward P/E around 23 for the S&P 500 and around 16 for small and midcaps. Those were the comparisons behind his preference for smaller stocks. He did not argue that the large-cap multiple required an immediate collapse.

Parets challenged the habit of using expensive-looking charts as automatic sell signals. They agreed that a high valuation could persist. Their disagreement was more about where the next returns would come from than whether one expensive reading could end a bull market.

Earnings revisions connected fundamentals with timing

Reitmeister described his background in quantitative fundamental research and his emphasis on earnings-estimate revisions. A company could be fundamentally appealing yet remain unproductive for an investor if the market had little reason to reassess it. Improving estimates supplied one potential reason.

He wanted stocks with favorable business characteristics that also had a chance to move over the next one to three months. That gave his approach some common ground with the hosts’ interest in momentum.

He said the Zen Ratings model considered 115 factors, spanning areas such as growth, value, financial strength, momentum and sentiment. He favored evaluating several dimensions together rather than allowing one familiar ratio to decide the selection.

A contrarian idea still needed evidence of a turn

Reitmeister and Parets also discussed heavily shorted stocks. Reitmeister warned that an apparently compelling case could remain stuck while short sellers retained control.

Parets agreed that high short interest alone was not a buy signal. His response was to sort those candidates by rate of change and wait for upward movement before participating. A disliked stock and a stock beginning to overcome that dislike were different stages in the process.

Reitmeister’s own requirement for smaller companies was similarly specific: attractive relative valuations had to come with healthy operations and earnings progress, not merely a smaller market capitalization.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-12-09 episode.

Was Reitmeister calling for a broad market collapse?

No. He expected early-year profit-taking and weaker mega-cap leadership, while remaining constructive on healthy small and midcaps.

Link to this answer

What was his forecast for the Russell 2000?

In the December 9, 2024 discussion, he forecast roughly a 10% to 15% gain for 2025, compared with a quieter year for the S&P 500.

Link to this answer

Why did he emphasize earnings revisions?

Improving estimates could provide a timely reason for investors to reassess a company, connecting favorable fundamentals with potential price movement.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .