Takeaways

#
  • Batnick wanted to give profitable trades time in a market with broadening participation, while still expecting pullbacks.
  • Celsius interested him through its base and continuation pattern rather than his use of the product.
  • He preferred familiar businesses because he could better manage his reactions to volatility.
  • Strazza stayed bullish but wanted fresh consolidations after many earlier setups had already advanced.

Michael Batnick’s Celsius trade was working, and he did not want the discomfort of having a profit to become his reason for selling it. In the July 7, 2025 Morning Show, he told Spencer Israel and Steve Strazza that a younger version of himself would have been much quicker to take money off the table.

The market had rebounded sharply from its spring lows, with participation broadening beyond the largest stocks. Batnick thought that environment deserved a willingness to hold winners. He also expected pullbacks and did not claim the favorable conditions would last indefinitely.

Celsius was a price decision

Batnick described Celsius as one of the first options ideas he had tried from Strazza’s Breakout Multiplier research. He was not deeply familiar with the company’s fundamentals and was not a regular customer. The price pattern was what interested him.

Strazza pointed to a tactical base, a recovery through VWAP and a smaller continuation range near the breakout level. Long calls expressed their view that the stock could continue higher from that structure.

For Batnick, the larger context mattered. More stocks were participating, and he wanted to give a successful position room rather than reflexively sell it because gains felt fragile. He said he had also been fortunate with purchases of Nvidia and CrowdStrike near the lows, while distinguishing those entries from a repeatable assumption that he could always buy the bottom.

Familiar businesses helped him tolerate volatility

Batnick was not trying to participate in every speculative corner of the rally. He preferred recognizable businesses and said he generally avoided companies he could not understand well enough to hold through a sharp decline.

His explanation was behavioral. If an unfamiliar stock fell 13%, he might panic and sell, only to watch it rebound. In a business he understood, with a clear uptrend still intact, he felt more comfortable considering an addition during a pullback.

He was describing the kind of exposure he could manage, rather than arguing that every falling stock deserved more money. He had little interest in forcing himself into a highly volatile name simply because it was moving rapidly or attracting attention.

The spring rebound tested existing plans

Batnick acknowledged that the speed of the recovery had surprised him. After several weeks, he had been tempted to reduce positions that had already appreciated considerably. The market kept advancing without the retest he and many others expected.

He described how that speed complicated decisions even for people who had planned to put cash to work during a decline. A price available on Monday could be far below the price available later in the same week. Waiting for the earlier opportunity to return could become its own source of paralysis.

For investors who sold during the April panic, he saw a reason to reassess risk tolerance rather than simply regret the trade. People could overestimate what they were comfortable losing during a bull market and forget that a major decline usually arrived with frightening news. The experience could help them recalibrate the portfolio and the returns they actually needed.

Earnings helped him filter the noise

Batnick relied heavily on the direction of corporate earnings and the spending behind them. He understood that reported earnings were backward-looking, but continued investment from companies such as Amazon and Microsoft gave him something more concrete to follow than the daily stream of conflicting headlines.

He was open to AI producing larger improvements in earnings and margins than investors expected, without claiming expertise about exactly how far that process would go. If spending or profits slowed, he would have different evidence to consider.

Strazza’s tactical preference was already shifting toward the next pause. Many of the attractive consolidations from earlier weeks had broken out and followed through. He remained bullish but wanted a new corrective phase, a higher low or another continuation pattern before broadly adding fresh exposure. Holding a working position and choosing the next entry were different decisions.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-07-07 episode.

Why did Batnick prefer recognizable companies?

He thought familiarity made it easier to handle a pullback within a clear uptrend. A sharp decline in an unfamiliar speculative stock was more likely to provoke a panicked exit.

Link to this answer

What did the fast rebound teach him about planning?

Prices recovered quickly enough to make delayed decisions difficult. He emphasized having a plan beforehand and using the experience to reassess realistic risk tolerance.

Link to this answer

Why was Strazza asking for a pullback while bullish?

Many earlier continuation patterns had already broken out and advanced. He wanted new consolidations and clearer tactical entries rather than adding indiscriminately after the move.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .