Takeaways

#
  • Sohn found energy's outflows interesting but said a large base could still carry an opportunity cost while investors waited for a catalyst.
  • Perz wanted oil above $80 to support an XLE breakout; Strazza acknowledged that his anticipated failed-breakdown signal had not yet occurred.
  • Their commodity discussion included the limits of available funds and the effect of futures-roll methods, not just the direction of the underlying market.
  • For Japan, Sohn separated a tactical bullish-yen position from his longer-term preference for dividing exposure between hedged and unhedged funds.

Investors had pulled money out of traditional energy funds, and Todd Sohn thought the retreat deserved attention. He was less certain about what would bring them back.

On the June 3, 2025 Morning Show, Sohn joined Steve Strazza and guest cohost Jason Perz to discuss a sector that had frustrated investors while other commodity markets improved. The large bases were there. So were the outflows. A sustained advance still needed to begin.

Money leaving energy did not supply an entry

Sohn described the reversal of money that had entered energy funds during the post-pandemic inflation wave. Some interest might have migrated into nuclear, infrastructure or natural-resource themes, he suggested, while traditional energy companies struggled to attract attention.

He also presented a small historical study of sectors that had roughly doubled their index weight over two years. Subsequent years had often been frustrating. He explicitly called the threshold arbitrary and the sample small, about five observations. It was context for energy's difficult stretch, rather than a precise timing model.

Sohn's concern was opportunity cost. Investors could recognize a promising base and still spend a long time waiting for it to produce a return. Higher oil prices, perhaps back into the $70s or $80s, might help. He did not identify a definite catalyst.

Perz supplied a more specific condition near the end of the program: oil above $80 would improve his confidence in an XLE breakout and a sustainable advance in energy shares. He wanted traders to wait for their signals instead of buying solely because the sector looked ready.

Strazza approached the same question through other commodities. Gold had already shown strength, and he was watching silver and copper for further improvement. If those metals continued breaking higher, he would be reluctant to bet on a collapse in oil.

That did not mean his anticipated oil reversal had occurred. He said explicitly that the failed-breakdown setup he was describing had not yet triggered. Avoiding a bearish bet and having a confirmed bullish entry were separate decisions.

A commodity view still needed a suitable vehicle

Strazza preferred expressing trades through his equity account, but he thought the available commodity funds left gaps. He wanted more ways to participate without managing separate futures positions and their sizing.

Sohn described some issuers' work on futures-roll methods, while Perz criticized how existing products had handled extreme conditions. Their discussion of USO and the disruption around negative oil prices in 2020 illustrated why a fund's construction mattered alongside the underlying commodity chart.

Sohn did not promise a wave of new commodity launches. He saw more product-development attention going to managed futures, cryptocurrency and leveraged single-stock funds. Perz thought a sustained weaker-dollar cycle could eventually revive interest in commodity products, but that was a possibility tied to the market environment.

Japan required a separate currency decision

Outside commodities, Sohn remained interested in developed international markets. Europe had the stronger trend, although he thought its extended advance could pause. Japan had spent months consolidating after the previous summer's currency disruption and was beginning to improve again.

Strazza favored unhedged Japanese exposure if the yen completed the bullish reversal he was watching. They contrasted EWJ, the iShares MSCI Japan ETF, with DXJ, the WisdomTree Japan Hedged Equity Fund.

Sohn distinguished that tactical currency view from the approach he generally suggested to longer-term advisers. Rather than trying to get both stocks and exchange rates right, he preferred splitting exposure between hedged and unhedged funds.

He also emphasized that country indexes change. His European sector-weight chart showed industrials taking a larger role, changing the exposure investors received from a broad regional fund. A decision to buy Europe or Japan therefore involved more than choosing a country: the sector mix and currency treatment helped determine what the position would actually own.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2025-06-03 episode.

What did Perz want to see before becoming more confident in energy shares?

He identified oil above $80 as a condition that could support an XLE breakout and a sustained industry advance. He told traders to wait for their own signals rather than anticipate the move.

Link to this answer

Why were energy outflows insufficient on their own?

Sohn thought the withdrawal of investor money had created an interesting reset, but he did not know the catalyst that would end the consolidation. Waiting in an inactive sector could still carry an opportunity cost.

Link to this answer

How did Sohn approach hedged versus unhedged Japan exposure?

He accepted unhedged EWJ as a tactical choice for someone expecting yen strength. For longer-term advisers, he preferred dividing exposure between hedged and unhedged funds because forecasting both the stocks and currency was difficult.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .