Takeaways

#
  • Improving breadth and reclaimed moving averages supported Subu’s market outlook, but the completed rebound reduced the appeal of a new broad-market entry.
  • He held a small energy position through XLE; Perz wanted more price momentum before committing to the potential recovery.
  • Subu expected gold to pause while favoring a possible dollar rebound, whereas Perz continued holding metals on a longer horizon.
  • His trading education emphasized testing why a strategy earns money across different market conditions.

Subu Trade brought a series of encouraging market studies to the May 13, 2025 Morning Show. Breadth was improving, major indexes had recovered their 200-day averages, and volatility had retreated. Yet by the end of his discussion with Spencer Israel and Jason Perz, he was not arguing that either stock-market bulls or bears had an obvious advantage at the current price.

The rally had already recovered much of the decline. From a new-entry perspective, he thought currencies offered better opportunities. That distinction between the market’s direction and the reward available after a sharp move ran through his analysis.

Breadth improved before every price chart recovered

Subu said the NYSE advance-decline line had come close to a record the previous day before easing late in the session. He saw that broad participation as favorable evidence for stocks over the following months. A record had not yet been confirmed in the observation he described.

He paired it with a historical study of the Nasdaq 100 reclaiming its 200-day moving average after more than 35 days below it. The tendency he reported was positive over subsequent months and a year.

He also challenged a common interpretation of that moving average. Markets can bottom and rally below it; the problem for a trend follower is often greater volatility. In his comparisons, nearby lookback periods produced broadly similar conclusions. He cared about the direction of the trend, rather than treating exactly 200 days as a uniquely powerful boundary.

Energy positioning interested him more than a large new equity bet

Subu disclosed a small energy-stock position. His sector-futures positioning chart showed dealers heavily net long and asset managers heavily net short relative to the period since the 2020 double bottom. He interpreted that contrast as a possible starting point for a sector recovery.

The 2020 comparison also mattered because energy had needed more time to bottom than the broad stock market. He thought another delayed recovery was possible. Depressed crude-oil sentiment supplied a second reason for interest.

Perz agreed that the positioning was worth watching but wanted more price momentum before becoming more interested. The two could like the same potential turn without choosing the same entry.

Asked how he expressed the view, Subu named the Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLE). He preferred the equity basket to using an oil or gas fund for the trade.

Gold and the dollar required different time horizons

Subu was less enthusiastic about gold immediately after its strong advance. He thought the stock-market recovery could coincide with gold moving sideways or correcting. His expectation was a pause, without requiring a collapse.

He also interpreted heavy bearish positioning in dollar futures as a reason to reconsider a dollar short. To him, the prospective reward favored a recovery in the currency more than extending the crowded bearish position.

Perz later described his own longer-term metals positions differently. He was still holding precious-metals exposure despite the pullback. Subu’s shorter-term caution and Perz’s continued holdings therefore reflected different decisions about timing, rather than a shared instruction to sell gold.

Understanding why a method works

Subu connected his testing habits to learning from two parents who traded independently. After school, they would ask him to study a market, write down his analysis and then compare it with theirs.

The lesson he emphasized was knowing why a trade made money. A rising market could reward a weak method for a time. Testing across rising, falling and sideways periods helped him examine whether the result came from the strategy or from a favorable environment.

He applied that question to trend-following entries as well. Repeated false breakouts could accumulate losses, so he looked for a market theme that could sustain a move alongside the price signal. He wanted a reason to take the next breakout, not simply evidence that the last few trades had worked.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2025-05-13 episode.

Why was Subu cautious about a new stock-market entry despite better breadth?

The rally had already recovered most of the decline he was measuring. He thought neither bulls nor bears had a clear advantage at that point and saw better prospective opportunities in currencies.

Link to this answer

What interested him in energy stocks?

He cited contrasting dealer and asset-manager positioning, depressed crude sentiment and the possibility that energy could recover later than the broad market. His disclosed position was small and used XLE.

Link to this answer

What trading lesson did he learn from his parents?

He learned to ask why a trade made money. Comparing analysis and testing different market environments helped distinguish a useful strategy from results that depended on a favorable market.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .