Takeaways
#- Shull saw missed-rally frustration and the desire to call a top as two possible motives for resisting an uptrend.
- Her regret exercise compared the emotional cost of acting and being wrong with the cost of staying out and being right.
- She viewed trading as a reactive activity, with less control and a less obvious score than conventional sports.
- Strazza described learning to distinguish monitoring a market from having to participate in it.
Making money had not stopped traders from feeling that they were getting the bull market wrong. On the October 9, 2025 Morning Show, Steve Strazza described a complaint he heard repeatedly: a good gain still felt inadequate because the position had gone higher after the sale.
Denise Shull, CEO of the ReThink Group, recognized the problem. Investors were comparing the result they had earned with another result they could imagine. The imagined alternative could dominate their thinking even when the actual account was profitable.
Her conversation with Strazza and Spencer Israel moved from that frustration to a practical question: when every decision carries the possibility of regret, which regret is the investor willing to accept?
Missing the rally can become a reason to fight it
JC Parets, who was traveling and could not join, had sent Israel a question about investors resisting an established uptrend. Shull identified two motives that could overlap. Someone who had missed the rally might feel it was already too late to participate. The same person might also want the satisfaction of identifying the top.
The balance differed by individual. A bearish view could contain more frustration about a missed opportunity, more desire to be right before everyone else, or some combination of the two.
Shull then considered the incentives around new highs. Existing holders could be pleased with their positions, while investors outside the market and short sellers might become potential buyers. In her account, a high price alone did not explain why those participants would suddenly want to sell.
Strazza preferred having a primary-trend process before reaching that emotional decision point. He offered a 200-day moving-average system as one way to participate earlier, rather than repeatedly deciding whether the latest high was finally too expensive.
Two uncomfortable choices can be compared
Shull illustrated her approach with a professional client who had suffered a large loss around a FedEx announcement. Later that year, he had a new market view but faced an uncomfortable choice. He could act on it and risk making an already difficult year worse. Or he could protect himself from another loss and risk watching his analysis prove correct without him.
They worked through both possibilities in detail. The client decided that missing a move he believed he understood would be more painful than taking another loss while following that view. Shull said he participated and the view subsequently worked.
The important decision happened before that outcome. He had identified two different sources of regret instead of treating inaction as emotionally costless. Shull's phrase for the exercise was to pick a flavor of regret: recognize what could hurt in either direction, then make the choice deliberately.
That also explained why profits did not automatically produce satisfaction. Selling, holding and never buying could each leave a different imagined result to measure against.
Trading does not have a final whistle
Another question from Parets concerned the endless nature of markets. Shull thought conventional sports psychology missed several features of the job. An athlete often tries to make something happen. A trader generally has to respond to conditions that the trader cannot control.
Surfing was her closer comparison. The task was to wait for a wave, recognize the opportunity and ride it. Wanting a wave badly did not cause one to arrive.
The score was also less obvious. A pullback in an investment could mean the thesis was failing or that an opportunity to add was developing. In football, losing field position was much easier to classify. And markets offered no offseason in which everyone could stop, assess the result and begin again together. Even an investor in cash was still watching the game continue.
Strazza connected that problem to his own early experience. He had made money during bull cycles and then returned too much of it during bear markets. Eventually he became more willing to step back when conditions no longer suited his approach. Watching the market and actively participating in it were different decisions. He could continue monitoring prices while spending less time trying to force another trade.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-10-09 episode.
Why can a profitable trade still feel disappointing?
Shull described the tendency to compare an actual gain with a larger result that was possible in hindsight. On the October 9, 2025 show, Strazza said traders repeatedly complained that they should have earned more even after a good trade.
How did Shull use regret to help a client make a decision?
They compared the possibility of taking another loss with the possibility of avoiding the trade and watching his market view prove right. The client chose the risk he was more willing to accept after examining both outcomes in detail.
Why did she compare trading with surfing?
A surfer responds to a wave rather than creating it. Shull used that distinction to explain why trying harder or wanting an opportunity more intensely cannot make market conditions cooperate.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .