Takeaways
#- Rosebee favored Joby after its stronger recent and year-to-date performance against Archer.
- Strazza distinguished leadership within a pair from sustained outperformance of the S&P 500.
- Archer's oversold relative-momentum reading weakened his assessment of its leadership.
- The speakers' different time horizons shaped how long they were willing to wait for the aircraft theme to develop.
Joby Aviation and Archer Aviation had risen while the broader market slipped. Riley Rosebee thought that strength deserved attention. Steve Strazza agreed, but wanted to distinguish the better stock in a pair from a sustained market leader.
Their September 24, 2025 Morning Show discussion used three different comparisons: performance during the latest down day, Joby against Archer over the year, and each stock against the S&P 500 over a longer period.
Those comparisons pointed in a similar direction within the pair, favoring Joby. They gave a less settled answer about whether electric-aircraft stocks were ready to become major leaders across speculative growth.
Rosebee saw buyers returning to Joby
Rosebee drew attention to the stocks after their gains during the previous session's market weakness. He said Joby had risen about 5.5% and was recovering from its early-September lows.
The year-to-date comparison was much more pronounced. His chart showed Joby up roughly 105%, against about 2% for Archer. For Rosebee, that was a reason to favor the stock investors had been rewarding.
Spencer Israel questioned whether the industry was developed enough to declare a business winner. He suggested owning both might make more sense than treating the stock-market comparison as a final verdict.
Rosebee accepted the distinction. He could see a case for exposure to both companies while allocating more to Joby, provided the relative price behavior continued to support that preference.
He was also clear that the operating timeline had moved. Earlier hopes for certification and commercial operations in 2025 had become less certain. His interest in the technology extended beyond the next launch date, but that longer horizon did not resolve the near-term business milestones.
Strazza compared the pair with the S&P 500
Strazza preferred Joby if he had to choose between the two. He was less persuaded that either stock had yet demonstrated the persistent relative strength seen in some other speculative industries.
He noted that Joby, despite its strong year-to-date performance, remained below its summer-2023 level relative to the S&P 500. A stock could therefore win a recent comparison against a peer while still recovering ground against the wider market.
Archer gave him another concern. Its relative trend had recently reached an oversold momentum reading. Strazza did not expect that behavior from a stock maintaining a sustained leadership regime.
He used Palantir's relative chart as a contrasting example. In his analysis, persistent leadership was accompanied by momentum that resisted becoming oversold for a long period. Joby had held up better than Archer on that recent test, reinforcing his preference within the pair.
The disagreement was partly about time
Rosebee was willing to wait for a technology he thought could reshape transportation. Strazza was looking for stocks capable of delivering substantial gains within the current market cycle.
That difference affected what each needed to see. Rosebee could tolerate a longer development period. Strazza wanted improving relative performance to become a tradeable advance soon, with an entry that matched his shorter horizon.
He thought the moment was worth watching because speculative growth was still attracting money. But he left open whether electric aircraft would become true cycle leaders or prove premature.
Rotation meant looking beyond the latest surge
The discussion broadened to quantum-computing stocks, where Strazza thought the immediate advance had become too extended to offer the same short-term edge. He was considering where profits could be redeployed.
Rocket Lab's chart interested him, along with the developing strength in the aircraft names. He described a process of following shorter-term relative strength and seeing whether it developed into a move lasting several months.
For Joby and Archer, the next evidence would come from price: whether the recent improvement persisted, whether Joby's lead survived, and whether either stock could sustain stronger performance against the broader market.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-09-24 episode.
Why did Rosebee favor Joby over Archer?
His chart showed much stronger year-to-date performance in Joby, along with strength during the previous session's market decline. He supported a larger Joby allocation within the pair while that price behavior continued.
Why did Strazza also compare the stocks with the S&P 500?
Winning against a peer did not necessarily mean leading the wider market. He noted that Joby was still below an earlier relative level against the index and examined whether momentum showed sustained leadership.
How did their time horizons change the discussion?
Rosebee was willing to wait for the technology's longer-term development. Strazza wanted meaningful outperformance in the current cycle, so he focused on whether recent relative strength could turn into a nearer-term trade.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .