Takeaways
#- Macke linked American Eagle’s improved outlook to advertising, denim demand and a valuation that could respond to better expectations.
- He was cautious on Lululemon ahead of that evening’s earnings, while McLaughlin disclosed shorts in Lululemon and Target.
- Macke favored retailers with stronger execution, distribution or distinctive business models, including Walmart, Amazon, Costco and Stitch Fix.
- Glick watched earnings reversals through VWAP in Ciena and Salesforce, using immediate price behavior rather than a holiday-season forecast.
Jeff Macke arrived on the September 4, 2025 Morning Show with a clear preference in apparel: American Eagle had become more interesting, while Lululemon faced a harder test.
American Eagle was already sharply higher after earnings. Macke thought the move reflected a business whose advertising, product mix and valuation were finally working together. He remained bullish on pullbacks heading toward Christmas, a forecast he made before that holiday season played out.
Steve Strazza and guest co-host Sean McLaughlin used the conversation to examine why retailers could produce such different results even when selling into the same consumer economy. Kenny Glick also joined with a shorter-term earnings watchlist.
American Eagle had a product reason to benefit
Macke had liked American Eagle's Sydney Sweeney advertising campaign when it appeared. His investment case went beyond the attention surrounding an ad.
Denim represented a substantial part of the company's sales mix. He estimated roughly 30% to 40%, making a stronger jeans cycle consequential for the business. If the campaign helped sell more of a product that already mattered, it could change earnings expectations.
He also saw a stock with a long history of going nowhere and a valuation that left room for better news. The combination of renewed relevance, a favorable clothing trend and improved expectations was what interested him.
McLaughlin disclosed that he owned American Eagle. Strazza acknowledged how little progress the stock had made over a much longer period. Macke's answer was that a weak long-term history did not prevent a useful trading opportunity when the business improved.
Lululemon faced a different fashion cycle
Macke worried that denim's revival could come at the expense of the athletic clothing category. Lululemon was due to report that evening, and he was skeptical ahead of the announcement.
He described competition from private brands such as Vuori and saw a company with less to offer shoppers moving toward jeans. He said he would be inclined to sell an earnings-driven spike and did not regard the shares as cheap until around $150.
That was a prospective assessment. The show took place before the earnings release, with both the report and the market's response still ahead.
McLaughlin later disclosed that he was short Lululemon and Target. He remained broadly bullish on stocks, but those individual positions allowed him to express a different view of weaker retailers.
Convenience was widening the gap between retailers
The discussion extended from apparel trends to the mechanics of shopping.
McLaughlin had started using Stitch Fix and was waiting for his second delivery. He liked being able to return unwanted items and give feedback that could improve the next selection. Macke, who disclosed a long position, thought the service had built a useful business that would be difficult for a new entrant to justify recreating.
Both saw room for better recommendations as the service learned more about a customer's preferences. Strazza still preferred trying a product in a store before ordering more online. The appeal depended on how each customer wanted to shop.
Macke considered Walmart, Amazon and Costco particularly strong operators. He emphasized distribution, supplier bargaining power and additional sources of cash flow. Costco's membership model stood apart from the economics of a conventional retailer, while Walmart's scale gave it more room to negotiate with suppliers.
Target, by contrast, needed visible operational improvement. Macke thought its incoming leadership had to demonstrate change rather than look like a continuation of the same approach.
Store visits raised questions worth checking
Strazza had visited crowded Florida outlets and noticed that Ralph Lauren was discounting less aggressively than some neighboring stores. That experience did not fit a simple picture of consumers refusing to spend.
Macke also saw encouraging back-to-school activity. He questioned whether gloomy sentiment surveys captured what shoppers were actually doing.
The company differences remained central. A crowded shopping center could coexist with weak execution at a particular brand. Macke wanted retailers whose products and operating model matched the demand he was seeing.
Earnings reactions offered a shorter-term trade
Glick's watchlist used a different clock. He was interested in whether an earnings selloff could reverse and reclaim volume-weighted average price.
He discussed that behavior in Ciena and watched Salesforce for a similar recovery, while flagging Hewlett Packard Enterprise after its own sharp selloff and recovery. McLaughlin also disclosed a position in Credo, another strong earnings mover.
Those intraday setups sat alongside Macke's apparel thesis, but the decisions were different. Glick wanted the immediate price reaction to confirm a trade. Macke was weighing whether a retailer's improved product cycle and execution could keep changing expectations over the months ahead.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-09-04 episode.
Why did Macke think American Eagle’s advertising mattered to earnings?
He estimated that denim accounted for roughly 30% to 40% of the sales mix. A campaign that helped sell more jeans could therefore matter to business expectations, particularly alongside an improving denim trend.
What worried Macke about Lululemon?
Before its September 4 earnings report, he saw competition from private brands and a fashion shift toward denim. He doubted that Lululemon had enough exposure to that shift and said he would be inclined to sell an earnings-driven spike.
What did McLaughlin like about Stitch Fix?
He liked receiving clothes at home, returning unwanted items and giving feedback that could improve subsequent selections. He had tried one delivery and was waiting for his second during the show.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .