Takeaways

#
  • Pies expected rate cuts to support a broader rally, while distinguishing that market narrative from a guaranteed economic outcome.
  • He would apply the same breadth threshold in real time that had been used in the historical test.
  • His firm had added bonds as possible construction-employment weakness increased the value of an equity hedge.
  • His oil model was bullish despite his own caution; he treated gold and other commodity groups separately.

Warren Pies expected a September Federal Reserve rate cut to help broaden the market’s rally. He was less certain that the underlying economy would respond as neatly as the market narrative suggested.

Appearing with Spencer Israel and Steve Strazza on the July 17, 2024 Morning Show, the 3Fourteen Research founder described a second-half outlook built around previously dormant, rate-sensitive areas. Home sales, car sales and other borrowing-dependent activity had lagged while a narrow group of stocks drove the bull market. Easier policy could bring more of that activity back.

Pies had made that case in his June outlook. The rotation was now happening more aggressively than he had anticipated.

A persuasive narrative with limits

Strazza asked whether the weak parts of the market simply needed lower interest rates to join the rally. Pies distinguished the economic outcome from the story investors might trade over the next six months. The reality was more complicated, but he believed the market could embrace that straightforward explanation.

He pointed to flows toward equal-weight exposure and small caps, with short covering and crowded relative trades contributing to the move. Homebuilders had been particularly strong.

Pies rejected the argument that falling mortgage rates necessarily hurt builders by releasing more existing homes onto the market. He expected a gradual decline in rates to improve affordability and support housing demand. He also saw a longer-term shortage of housing, while acknowledging that builder stocks were extended in the short run.

Keep the signal consistent with its test

The interview then turned to breadth thrusts, which measure a rapid expansion in the number of stocks participating. Strazza’s team used a 55% threshold for its 20-day new-high measure. The latest reading was 54.87%, close enough that Strazza wanted to round it up.

Pies said the answer depended on how the signal had been tested. If the historical test required 55% and did not include rounding, he would keep that same rule in real time. A near miss would not technically qualify.

He also wanted multiple signals to confirm one another. Some thrusts around late 2021 and early 2022 had made him wary of relying on them without considering the policy backdrop. He was more willing to trust breadth expansion when the Fed appeared poised to ease than when further tightening lay ahead.

Bonds offered a different kind of protection

Pies said his discretionary portfolio had moved from an unusually large cash position to an overweight in bonds and duration roughly three or four weeks earlier. The change reflected emerging economic risks as well as his expectation of lower yields.

His team monitored residential-construction employment as part of its recession framework. Their model was beginning to suggest possible job losses, and he described multifamily construction as already weak. That made bonds more useful to him as a potential hedge for equities.

A recession was not his base case. He expected a soft landing and distinguished a modest policy adjustment from the rapid emergency cuts associated with a downturn. He also acknowledged how few historical soft landings were available for comparison.

His oil model and his judgment disagreed

Pies’s crude-oil model was bullish, even though he personally expected a weaker second half for oil. He said the signal pointed toward roughly $100 oil within the next quarter and that he would defer to the model. He also described its historical accuracy as only about 68%, emphasizing that even a strong signal could fail.

His own reservations included potential supply returning from OPEC, rising recession risks and the possibility of a reduced geopolitical premium. That caution did not extend to every commodity. He remained bullish on gold and treated industrial metals, oil, energy stocks and precious metals as separate exposures.

Natural gas interested him because clients investing in data centers were confronting their energy requirements, though he considered the market difficult to time. He spoke favorably of Cheniere Energy (LNG) and Williams (WMB), identifying Williams as a longstanding recommendation and emphasizing the importance of its Transco pipeline.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2024-07-17 episode.

Would Pies round a 54.87% breadth reading up to 55%?

He said the live rule should match the backtest. If the test required 55% without a rounding function, he would treat 54.87% as not technically triggering the signal.

Link to this answer

Why had his firm increased its bond allocation?

He expected lower yields as the Fed approached a rate cut and saw emerging risks in residential-construction employment. Those risks made bonds more useful to him as a potential hedge, even though he still expected a soft landing.

Link to this answer

How did he reconcile a bullish oil signal with his bearish outlook?

He said he would defer to the model while explaining his reservations to clients. The model suggested roughly $100 oil within the next quarter, but he emphasized that its approximately 68% historical accuracy still left room for failure.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .