Takeaways
#- The break above 4,200 carried more weight with Roque because more stocks were participating.
- He dated the small-cap outperformance to early May. A long-IWM, short-SPY trade was one plausible explanation, not an identified investor position.
- Of materials, energy and industrials, he preferred industrials after the sector held its rising 40-week average and bounced relative to the S&P.
For about a year, John Roque had called 4,200 the S&P 500’s Mendoza Line. Sellers had turned the index back there often enough that he gave the bears the benefit of the doubt below it. Now the S&P was above 4,200. On the June 8, 2023 Morning Show, Patrick Dunuwila asked whether breaking that line had actually changed his outlook. Roque said it had. An important ceiling had given way, and the advance was starting to reach beyond seven large stocks.
The timing mattered. The strongest recent moves in small caps had drawn attention in the previous few sessions. Roque traced the improvement back to early May. He estimated that small caps had outperformed large caps by almost 6% since then. Steve Strazza was looking at the speed of the latest move: in the previous session the Russell had gained close to 2% while the S&P had slipped about 0.4%. They agreed on the strength. They didn't quite agree on what to call it.
Why Roque wouldn't call it a wholesale rotation
The iShares Russell 2000 ETF (IWM) was gaining on the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY). Roque could easily imagine a hedge fund buying IWM and selling SPY against it. Both sides of the trade could be put on quickly, and the smaller companies could outperform without the manager having to choose a single one of them.
He had a harder time picturing a manager with a big Nvidia position selling a quarter of it, then sending analysts out to find 40 small companies to replace it. Position sizes that matter to a large fund aren't necessarily easy to build in smaller stocks. The ETF ratio gave him evidence that the trade was working. It didn't identify who had placed it or what, if anything, they'd sold to fund it.
Industrials had a better chart than materials
Dunuwila asked him to choose among three groups that had caught a bid: materials, energy and industrials. Materials still looked challenged to Roque. Industrials had held their rising 40-week moving average. Weekly momentum was positive, if hardly emphatic. And relative to the S&P, industrials had bounced from a trend line that went back to the pandemic low. The sector had shown him several reasons to prefer it without requiring a forecast about what might lift industrial profits.
That didn't mean the time had come to sell every technology winner. Roque drew a distinction between owning Nvidia (NVDA) and making a new purchase after its steep advance. By his measure, it had recently traded about 100% above its 200-day moving average. The company could be worth more a year later and still be a poor short-term entry at twice that average. If he'd owned a stock that far above its trend, Roque said, he'd have quietly congratulated himself and taken some off.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-06-08 episode.
Why did Roque care about S&P 4,200?
It had repeatedly stopped the index for about a year. Getting above it while participation improved changed his previously cautious reading.
Did Roque think Nvidia had to fall?
He said the stock could be higher a year later. His objection was to expecting a quick gain from a new purchase when the shares had recently traded around twice their 200-day average.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .