Takeaways
#- The Mueller Water August $30 calls were closed for $0.75 after a $1.60 entry, preserving part of the premium while realizing a loss.
- McLaughlin lowered the underlying-price stop on the April ITB $95/$90 put spread to $97 as expiration approached.
- His new trades included a Tesla range position, bullish Comstock and Enphase ideas, and an options pair involving gold and silver.
- He wanted a high-volume reversal and subsequent follow-through before becoming more comfortable with the broader market.
Sean McLaughlin entered the April 3, 2025 Options Jam Session acknowledging that the market had reacted more severely to the tariff announcement than he expected. His response was to review the positions already on the books and the conditions that would change his risk.
The update included one closed loss, one revised stop and several recently opened trades. His broader market view remained tentative: the volatility index gave him some hope, but he was still waiting for evidence that a low had formed.
Mueller Water’s exit preserved part of the call premium
McLaughlin reported closing the Mueller Water Products trade late the previous week. He had bought August $30 calls for $1.60 and exited at $0.75.
The position lost money. He nevertheless preferred the partial recovery of premium to the complete loss he had allowed for when sizing the trade.
For long-call positions, McLaughlin said he began with the possibility that the option could become worthless. He sized the position so that such a loss would fit within his portfolio risk budget. Exiting before the remaining premium disappeared left him with less damage than that full-loss scenario.
Mueller Water was the only closed position he reported since the prior update.
ITB’s approaching expiration changed the stop management
The homebuilder trade was moving in the intended direction. McLaughlin held an April put spread in ITB: long the $95 put and short the $90 put, purchased for a $1.70 debit.
Because expiration was approaching that month, he wanted to manage the stop more aggressively. He lowered the underlying-price stop to $97 and planned to reassess it daily.
His reference was approximately the prior three to five days’ highs, with some discretion. The $97 area aligned with the previous session’s high, so he thought it might remain useful for another few days if the decline continued.
He also had a resting order to sell the spread for a profit. That order had not filled during the update. Further weakness in ITB could let him lower the stop again or bring the spread to its exit target.
ITB was the only position whose stop he changed in the broadcast.
The new positions expressed different expectations
McLaughlin described a delta-neutral Tesla position built around an expected range of roughly $220–$320 over the next couple of weeks. He was looking for the range to contain the stock, rather than expressing an outright bullish or bearish view.
Comstock Resources was a bullish position. Its resilience during the weak session encouraged him, though he considered the trade too new to judge.
Enphase Energy was another bullish attempt, and it was not working yet. He described a two-part approach intended to catch a turn that might be untidy. He expected to give the position room and time, while acknowledging that his entry could be early.
Gold and silver supplied a relative-value idea
A newly opened options pairs trade was less typical of McLaughlin’s approach. He was examining the divergence between gold’s advance and silver’s continued base-building.
His scenario allowed for gold to pause or pull back, silver to catch up, or both developments together. The relationship between the two metals was the basis for the trade.
That made it different from simply declaring that both commodities had to rise. He was looking for the gap in their recent behavior to narrow.
A hopeful volatility reading still needed market follow-through
At the time of the broadcast, VIX had not exceeded the earlier spikes McLaughlin was watching or moved above 30. He took some encouragement from that, while allowing for more selling before the session ended.
He wanted a high-volume flush followed by a meaningful recovery and additional strong-volume advances over the following days. Even a dramatic intraday reversal would need follow-through before he became more comfortable acting bullishly.
Until those conditions developed, he favored staying tactical and taking profits more quickly when trades worked.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-04-03 episode.
What changed in the ITB trade?
McLaughlin lowered the underlying-price stop to $97 and planned daily reviews as April expiration approached. The position was a long $95 put and short $90 put spread bought for a $1.70 debit.
Was the Mueller Water trade profitable?
No. He paid $1.60 for the August $30 calls and exited at $0.75. He preferred recovering part of the premium to losing the entire amount allocated to the trade.
What was the gold-silver pairs trade intended to capture?
McLaughlin wanted gold to pause or pull back, silver to catch up, or both. The idea depended on a change in their relative performance rather than requiring both metals to rise.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .