Takeaways
#- McLaughlin sold half his Oracle calls before earnings and the rest after a stock-price stop, leaving a combined gain before costs.
- His Hershey puts still lost money, although he said higher implied volatility helped preserve their value.
- He exited Insperity puts after the shares closed above his lowered $83.50 stop.
- Microsoft’s $40 spread-sale order was still pending, with an alternative exit if the stock reached the $470 short strike.
Oracle’s earnings reaction went against Sean McLaughlin’s bullish position, but selling part of the trade before the announcement helped him finish with a gain. In the December 12, 2024 Options Jam Session, he walked through that result alongside two bearish trades he had closed at losses.
He was also becoming more selective about the broader market. Weakening participation beneath the indexes made him expect a change in the character of the advance. He was not calling for a bear market; he expected that simply buying almost anything would become less effective.
Oracle’s first sale came before the announcement
McLaughlin had bought Oracle June $200 calls for $10.75 in October. His plan included selling half the position shortly before the company reported earnings. He wanted to reduce exposure to the announcement while potentially benefiting from a pre-earnings increase in option premium.
He reported selling that first half for $17.50 about five minutes before the market closed. The earnings reaction subsequently pushed the stock lower. After Oracle closed below his stock-price stop, he sold the remaining half for $8.65.
The second sale was below his original option purchase price, but the earlier partial sale was enough to leave the combined trade profitable before costs. He emphasized that the decision to reduce exposure had been planned in advance, rather than improvised after seeing the earnings reaction.
Hershey’s volatility cushioned a losing directional call
Hershey was a different outcome. McLaughlin had bought February $175 puts for $5.50 near the end of October, looking for further weakness in the stock. The initial decline had helped, but the shares then recovered sharply.
He attributed the sudden jump to buyout speculation. He waited for the trading day after the stock closed above his stop to exit, describing wide bid-ask spreads during the initial move.
Despite the unfavorable stock direction, he sold the puts for $4.25. His explanation was that the new uncertainty had increased option premiums. He had entered when he considered implied volatility relatively low, and its subsequent rise helped preserve part of the puts’ value.
He still called it a losing trade. The $1.25 difference between his purchase and sale prices was a loss before costs, even if it was smaller than he would have expected from the stock’s move alone.
Insperity’s rebound triggered the other bearish exit
McLaughlin had also been positioned for a decline in Insperity through January $75 puts bought for $2. The stock initially moved in his direction before finding support around the low $70s and recovering.
He had lowered his stock-price stop to $83.50. Once the shares closed above that reference, he exited near the next trading day’s open, receiving $0.72 for the puts. He presented it as an ordinary losing position closed under the existing plan.
Microsoft’s next exit was an order, not a completed sale
The Microsoft position remained open. McLaughlin held a January $420/$470 bull call spread and raised the underlying-stock stop to $420.
He also added a good-till-canceled order to sell the spread for $40. That was 80% of its $50 maximum expiration value per share if the spread remained intact. The maximum profit would also deduct the net premium paid; the strike difference was not itself the trade’s profit.
If Microsoft reached the $470 short strike before that limit order filled, he planned to sell the spread at the available price. He had not reported either exit occurring during the episode. The standing order gave him a specific way to take profits without waiting for every remaining dollar of potential spread value.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-12-12 episode.
How did the Oracle trade remain profitable after a negative earnings reaction?
McLaughlin sold half the calls for $17.50 before the announcement, then sold the remainder for $8.65. The combined proceeds exceeded the original $10.75 purchase price before costs.
Why did Hershey’s puts retain value while the stock rose?
McLaughlin attributed that to increased option premiums as buyout speculation raised uncertainty. He nevertheless exited for less than he paid.
Was Microsoft’s $40 sale already complete?
No. He had placed a standing limit order. He also planned to exit if the stock reached $470 before the order filled.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .